NATALIE Appleton’s son Ace looked every inch the grown-up rockstar as he attended a new Bowie exhibition with his famous Mum.
The pair posed on the red carpet at the opening night of David Bowie: You’re Not Alone at The Lightroom in London.
Sign up for the Showbiz newsletter
Thank you!
Natalie poses with her rockstar son Ace at the Bowie exhibitionCredit: GettyNatalie and Ace spent some quality time together at the eventCredit: GettyNatalie posed proudly on the red carpet alongside Ace who towered over herCredit: Getty
Natalie also has an older daughter, Rachel, 33, from a previous relationship with Dreamboys stripper Carl Robinson.
Despite their fame, Natalie and Liam have kept their family life relatively private, choosing to let their son carve out his own path.
And it seems that approach has paid off, with Ace now making a name for himself on the London music scene in his own right.
Following in the footsteps of his musical parents, Ace is bass guitarist for the Camden-based group, Pedestrian Band, with his proud Mum known to plug his music on her socials.
Ace’s band Pedestrian are still emerging on the London indie scene, but they’re already turning heads with their experimental sound.
The trio have released their debut EP and built a cult following, earning a reputation as one of Camden’s most exciting up-and-coming acts.
The exhibition received a thumbs up from AceCredit: GettyAce’s Auntie is All Saints star Nicole AppletonCredit: GettyAce is making a name for himself on the Camden music sceneCredit: Instagram/Natalie Appleton
Prodigy star Liam and Natalie have been a couple for 25 yearsCredit: Getty – Contributor
While he isn’t relying on his famous surname, Ace is well-connected in music, with cousin Gene Gallagher, son of Nicole Appleton and Liam Gallagher.
Meanwhile, Natalie and her sister Nicole shot to fame in 1996 alongside Shaznay Lewis and Melanie Blatt in the girl band All Saints.
The group proved a massive hit and brought fans songs like Pure Shores, Black Coffee, and Never Ever.
The foursome became huge stars, with Nicole and Natalie going on to date some big celebrities, before settling down with Liam.
Nicole once had a high-profile with Robbie Williams between 1997 and 1999, which included an engagement and a terminated pregnancy.
Natalie and Ace attended the launch of Lightroom’s latest exhibition of immersive Bowie content projected onto it’s 11-metre-high walls and floor.
The hour-long experience features live recordings, interviews and unseen footage from the David Bowie Archive.
With a huge sound system and Bowie as narrator, it’s considered the closest to experiencing the late icon live.
Tickets are priced from £25 for adults and £15 for students and concessions.
Nicole Appleton and Liam Gallagher shortly after Gene was born in 2001Credit: News Group Newspapers LtdAll Saints were one of the biggest acts of the 90sCredit: Getty
A BRIT rock back have been forced to cancel an impending gig after an “unexpected medical situation”.
Enter Shikari were due to play a gig at Dublin Academy in Ireland this evening but have been forced to withdraw.
Sign up for the Showbiz newsletter
Thank you!
Enter Shikari have pulled the plug on their Dublin gigCredit: GettyThe band revealed a medical situation had forced them to axe tonight’s gig plansCredit: Getty
The band kept details sparse but confirmed a “medical reason” was behind their decision to pull the plug on the gig in the Irish capital city.
Issuing a statement, the band revealed they were gutted to be unable to complete the concert as planned.
The band said: “Due to a medical situation both unexpected and beyond our control, we’re sad to have to say we’re having to postpone tonight’s Dublin Academy show.
“If you know anything about us, you know that cancelling/postponing shows is always the absolute last resort once all other options have been exhausted, especially at this short notice.
“We’re very sorry for any inconvenience this causes anyone.
“We’re in conversation with our Irish promoter and will immediately start looking at potential date to reschedule to.
“Thank you in advance for your understanding, and we hope we can see you as soon as possible. ES x.”
Their fans were quick to issue their well-wished amid the uncertain situation.
One penned: “Sending you guys so much love hope you’re all ok.”
Another went on to write: “Hope all is ok – let us know when you’re planning to be back in Ireland!”
A third then said: “Absolutely gutted as flew here solo from Brighton especially *but* sending everyone so much love and hope, and thank you for still being the reason I finally visited Ireland!”
Before a fourth commented: “Sending love as this can’t have been an easy decision, get well soon.”
Whilst a fifth comment read: “Health first always. Hope all is ok. We go again even harder on the rescheduled show to make up for this. Grá mór.”
The band were first formed in 1999 and adopted their current identity in 2003.
Their debut album, Take to the Skies, was eventually released in 2007 and reached number four on the UK Albums Chart.
Their seventh record, released in 2023, became their first chart-topper.
The group’s latest record, surprise released earlier this month, managed to chart at number 16.
The band had been to play in the Irish capitalCredit: Getty
ROBBIE WILLIAMS could be getting back in the studio — this time with boyband Blue.
It comes after Rob wrote the lads’ new single Flowers, which is on the setlist for the UK leg of their 25th Anniversary world tour.
Sign up for the Showbiz newsletter
Thank you!
The Sun’s Emily with Antony Costa, Simon Webbe, Lee Ryan and Duncan JamesCredit: UnknownRobbie co-wrote Blue’s new single FlowersCredit: Getty
Biz on Sunday’s Emily caught up with Blue members Antony Costa, Simon Webbe,Lee Ryan,and Duncan James at the Eventim Apollo in Hammersmith, West London, this week.
The band are on their milestone tour following the release of seventh studio album Reflections.
Antony said: “We would love to work with Robbie’s people and that is the conversation that is happening.
“Karl Brazil (Robbie’s music director) is very much on our side.
“He is championing Blue and us and the lads have spoken to Karl separately and together.
“You never know, watch this space.”
Antony revealed that Robbie reached out to the band after watching their story on the BBC documentary Boybands Forever.
He said: “It resonated with him because we were all young and he was a young lad in Take That.
“Take That went on a different journey than us, but we still wanted that same goal.
“Robbie has always been there and he’s been a big supporter of me and the boys.”
Duncan said: “We’re so lucky that after 25 years we’re still getting to sell out gigs, still touring around the world and we’ve got the adoration from the fans.
Blue are on the UK leg of their 25th Anniversary world tourCredit: Mark Passmore Photography
“We’ve had the nod from Robbie to write that song for us, so it’s almost like the industry is opening the door again and we’re feeling the love.”
Of their new hit Flowers, Duncan added: “A lot of people have said it sounds like a Robbie song as well.”
Blue are one of the few bands still touring with an original line-up.
Simon said: “One of the reasons we have stood the test of time is all four of us wanted to be in a boyband.
“Most are full of members who want to be solo artists but weren’t good enough.
“So all of a sudden you’ve got egos.
“We don’t understand why bands argue or why they don’t get on because when you’re a team, you’re a team player.”
The boys are playing at London’s Royal Hospital Chelsea on June 11.
I will get my prosecco and picnic blanket ready.
Tickets are on sale at myticket.co.uk.
Meanwhile, the band revealed Ellie Goulding got them to perform at her 70s-themed baby shower in January, ahead of the birth of her daughter Iris.
The boys sang their 2002 track One Love with Ellie.
Duncan added: “We didn’t realise she was a big fan of our music.”
SAM THOMPSON is stepping down from his role on Love Island: Aftersun.
Sam Thompson is stepping down from his role on Love Island: AftersunCredit: Shutterstock Editorial
But an insider revealed: “Sam’s schedule is jam-packed and producers are going in a different direction so there’ll be a bit of a shake-up on Aftersun.
“ITV is really keen on harnessing new talent, especially plucking from its pool of influencers and TikTokkers to boost ratings.
“Sam may well return as a guest, but he won’t be a regular.”
A spokeswoman for Sam said: “He absolutely loved his time as part of the Love Island team and the show will always have a special place in his heart.”
NOEL SHOWS HIS SCENTS OF STYLE
NOEL GALLAGHER might have a thing for cigarettes and alcohol – but he also likes more refined smells, too.
The Oasis great shares the same taste in scent as suave Thirties and Forties playwright and composer Noel Coward.
Noel Gallagher visited bespoke perfumer Azzi Glasser at her London studioCredit: Shutterstock EditorialNoel chose the scent favoured by Noel CowardCredit: PopperfotoNoel is also a fan of her £259 Mystere VetivertCredit: Supplied
He visited bespoke perfumer Azzi Glasser at her London studio.
Azzi, who has created scents for Kylie Minogue, Tom Hardy And Jude Law, charges £1,500 for a “fragrance workshop” to create a one-off scent to match your personality.
Noel spent £400 on candles and chose Vetiver scent by Floris London – favoured by Noel Coward.
Azzi revealed that Noel is also a fan of her £259 Mystere Vetivert.
She said: “It smells like you’re wearing a million dollars.”
IS THAT MADGE? CORSET IS
MADONNA returned to Coachella in the same jacket and corset she performed in 20 years ago as she joined Sabrina Carpenter for her headline set on Friday.
The sparkling duo performed the Queen of Pop’s hits Vogue and Like A Prayer before launching into a new song, I Feel So Free, from Madonna’s long-rumoured new album, Confessions II, set for release on July 3.
Madonna joined Sabrina Carpenter on stage at CoachellaCredit: SuppliedMadonna wore the same jacket and corset she performed in 20 years agoCredit: SuppliedThe pair performed Vogue and Like A PrayerCredit: Supplied
Madonna was delighted to stand four inches taller than Sabrina, who is just under 5ft.
She told the crowd: “The other thrilling thing I need to point out to everybody right now is this is probably the first time I’ve ever performed with someone who’s shorter than me.
“So, thank you for giving me that experience.”
In response, Sabrina shouted, “Amen!”.
Cute as a button.
Madonna said she was happy to share the stage with someone shorter than herCredit: SuppliedThey also performed new Madonna song I Feel So FreeCredit: Supplied
’ROACHES ROLLING OUT AGAIN?
ROLLING STONES fans reckon there could be live dates on the horizon under their alias, The Cockroaches.
Rumours started after the rockers updated their website to include a poster of a 1977 surprise gig at El Mocambo Club in Toronto, attended by Princess Margaret , which was billed as a gig by The Cockroaches.
Rolling Stones fans reckon there could be live dates on the horizon under their alias, The CockroachesCredit: Supplied
Keith Richards also posted a cryptic comment saying: “Great fun though huh?
A good rhythm section, a couple of mates, where else can you go.”
A source said: “There is a lot of buzz about this as next year it will be 50 years since the Stones last played live as The Cockroaches.”
TALIA MAR is hoping to work with DJ Sigala again.
The pair collaborated on 2022 dance track Stay The Night.
Asked if she would like to work with him this year, Talia told me: “Oh my God, yes. I was talking to him the other day. He is summer. I was like, ‘Can we get some new music please, because it is summer?’.”
Talia who has released new track Lady, will play at London’s Courtyard Theatre on May 16.
She said: “I want it to be really casual, I don’t want it to be glitz and glamour.
“Stripping it down is a really lovely moment.”
TIM’S CHILL TIME DOWN TO A TEE
TIMOTHEE CHALAMET has been enjoying some chill-out time on the beach.
After watching Justin Bieber at Coachella with his girlfriend Kylie Jenner last weekend, he headed for Miami to relax.
AFTER the whirlwind success of No1 hit Stick Season, Noah Kahan didn’t rush back into the studio.
In fact, he stopped completely. Facing writer’s block and still processing everything that had happened, he stepped away for six months, forced to rethink not just the music, but what success meant.
Sign up for the Showbiz newsletter
Thank you!
Noah Kahan is back with a new album, The Great DivideCredit: Patrick McCormackNoah’s 2022 album Stick Season sold over four million copies and had billions of global streamsCredit: Stephen Keable
His 2022 album Stick Season — rooted in Vermont and exploring mental health, identity and small-town life — transformed the singer from a cult folk artist into a global name.
Topping the charts in the UK, the record was also certified multi-platinum in the US, where it sold over four million copies and had billions of global streams.
Kahan was nominated for a Grammy for Best New Artist and the emotionally raw, nostalgic and deeply personal record was widely seen as one of the defining albums of the decade.
“I just couldn’t write for a while,” he confesses. “When I first got off the road, I didn’t make any music in a long time.
“I spent months not doing anything and it was painful because I like to be busy.
“It took so much strength for me to push that feeling away.
“I’m aware of how rare the moment was, how big the moment was and how lucky and fortunate I was, but my whole life I was trying to prove to people that I had a place here. So when the huge moment was happening, instead of being like, ‘Yeah, I made it’, I was like, ‘Oh my god, how am I going to stay here?’.”
That pressure quickly took its toll. Kahan said: “Writer’s block is such a lonely feeling — it makes you feel like your value’s been taken away. I felt completely unable to open up about it, but I ended up reaching out to friends.
“Marcus Mumford really helped. He understood what it’s like to be under a lot of pressure and afraid of failing and gave me great advice.”
Kahan also had to redefine success. It was not chasing numbers — just being able to make music was enough.
He says: “I learned the hard way about burnout. Success is a double-edged sword. I’ve always said if I had any, or if my tour sells out, I’d be happy. But the second it sells out, you’re looking at the next thing to achieve.
“Starting off this new album was really scary. I had to realise I didn’t need to be the biggest artist in the world or where Stick Season took me. I didn’t need to be successful to be loved.”
Kahan is in London for a few days to promote The Great Divide, his fourth studio album, which is out next Friday.
Taking time off to reset both mentally and emotionally was essential to writing again.
“I’ve struggled with my mental health,” he says candidly.
“But I was struggling more than anybody knew. I’ve struggled with anxiety, depression and body dysmorphia, but it was the OCD that I hadn’t figured out.
“I was diagnosed with OCD last year. It’s not about washing my hands a thousand times — it’s obsessive thinking. I was struggling with a lot of self-esteem and confidence issues, but I’d never dealt with anything so acutely like OCD. I’m supposed to be the singer who’s open about his mental health, but I felt so much shame.
“I needed medical intervention and therapy, and I didn’t want to be open about that because I was afraid. It was frightening as I’d been stripped of
this thing I loved.
“I couldn’t express myself through music any more, and so I didn’t tell anybody and it came to a breaking point.” Through help and time, Kahan started to recognise his disorder in ways he hadn’t before.
“Now I wake up knowing my day is not going to be decided by what I see on my phone,” he says when discussing how therapy has helped him.
“Before, I’d have 700 brilliant words of praise, but it would be the one negative word that would shatter me. For a long time, I thought I was crazy.”
Kahan is focused on bringing his album to the stageCredit: Patrick McCormack
In August 2025, Kahan married his longtime partner Brenna Nolan, bringing a new sense of stability to his life.
The singer has also made a Netflix documentary — Noah Kahan: Out Of Body. It captures this difficult period, which he sees as part of his healing.
He says: “Making the film was a strange but amazing process. Having people follow you around took time to get used to, but they captured a really honest moment for me. Watching it back with my family was emotional. It showed how we really are.
“It was hard seeing how unhappy I was then, but in the end, it told a beautiful story.”
He adds: “My family are on the new record. I love the song American Cars. It’s about my sister.
“Whenever things were tough at home, she’d drive up from New York in a rental car, sunglasses on, just a total badass.
“She’s a surgeon, she just gets things done. She’d come back and help us through it, and the song came from that. Like, you need to come home and help fix this.”
The Great Divide is an album about friendship, miscommunication, regret and personal growth, and the title track became the guiding, emotional “north star” of the record.
He says: “Yeah, The Great Divide is really about a friendship that didn’t work out — one where I wasn’t able to express myself.
“And then there’s a song, Dan, which is about the opposite — being open, telling each other how much you care, facing hard truths. It ends in a way that really encapsulates the whole record. It’s probably my favourite song we made.
“There are a lot of stories,” he adds.
“It’s very emblematic of my childhood and a lot of people’s, young men in particular. Talking about feelings or asking difficult questions can feel like more discomfort than it’s worth, but the consequence is you don’t really know someone as well as you think you do.”
Noah says of his new album: ‘The Great Divide is really about a friendship that didn’t work out — one where I wasn’t able to express myself’Credit: Patrick McCormack
It’s an expansive album with 17 tracks, including the gorgeous We Go Way Back, Willing And Able, Haircut and Porch Light.
He adds: “I can’t wait to see crowds singing back Willing And Able, and Haircut started from that idea of someone coming back to town changed — like they’ve outgrown it. I felt like I’d become that person, only going home for inspiration instead of really being there.
“The song is almost someone singing to me, saying, I’m glad you’ve figured things out, but at least I’m still here and still real. You’ll leave again, and we’ll still be here. That’s what it’s about.
“Then, Porch Light is really about my biggest fear — how I’ve changed.
“I worry about going home and feeling like people see me differently, like I’ve become this ‘Hollywood’ version of myself, too big for where I’m from. That my relationship with Vermont has been changed by success and leaving Vermont for Nashville.
“But my family has always kept me grounded. They’re so happy for me. I wanted to write about that fear you have in your head before you even pick up the phone.
“You’re always anticipating what people might think. But there’s a silver lining in Porch Light. It’s about people saying, ‘We still care about you, we’ll still be here — but you need to figure things out first’.”
And that sense of place runs throughout the album.
“Yeah, the first and last songs really frame the album — I wanted them to feel like an intro and an outro,” Kahan says.
“The first track, End Of August, is this big, building track about that time of year in Vermont . . . It’s that moment when the tourists leave and the people who live there can finally come out of hibernation — like, ‘They’re gone’.”
He’s been working with Stick Season collaborator Gabe Simon, The National’s Aaron Dessner — best known for his work with Taylor Swift, Bon Iver and, more recently, Gracie Abrams — plus Ed Sheeran and Mumford & Sons.
Kahan says: “Gabe and I are really close — we went through a lot making Stick Season, so on this album we leaned on each other. He’s like a brother and the perfect person to go through this with.”
Noah will be in the UK, including three nights at London’s O2 in NovemberCredit: Patrick McCormack
Aaron Dessner brought calm, structure and creative balance to the process.
“Aaron came in early on, but I was intimidated at first,” admits Kahan. “I looked him up on Wikipedia and was terrified of his success. This guy’s a legend.
“This was where Taylor Swift writes and Justin Vernon (Bon Iver), who works with Aaron, is my hero. Aaron has a magic to his music — a real understanding of what an artist is trying to say. But he’s a sweet, calm man who lives a very humble life in upstate New York on a farm.
“I needed him to stabilise me creatively. He is regimented in how he makes music and I need a routine. He is an amazing producer and this album sounds so f*****g cool because of what Aaron did.”
The sound on the new album is more expansive than Kahan’s earlier music and includes horns, guitar and richer production.
He says: “Honing on a sound and a theme started the process. Aaron’s place had dirt bikes, fishing rods and skeet shooting — all the things that I grew up doing.
“We couldn’t make the music in Vermont this time and the setting was really important, feeling connected to nature and beauty.
“It’s hard for me to make music in a city. Whenever I’m in a city, all I write is, ‘Get me out of the city’ songs.”
He adds: “We were also still in the middle of touring and I was over the Stick Season songs.
“There’s a lot of electric guitar on the new record, and bouzouki and mandocello, instruments we haven’t really used before. It’s a new confidence, but having spent three years on the road, I just want to make music that’s exciting to play live.”
It’s the connection with his audience that remains key.
He says: “I love it when I see fans singing back my songs as it means they’re feeling it.
“I’m always honoured when someone says my music has helped them to reach out for help. Though it can be overwhelming when people tell me they’re struggling with difficult thoughts.
“I don’t always feel equipped to handle that and I worry I’m not helping in the way they need. It’s hard when you feel you’re letting someone down.”
Now, his attention is focused on bringing the album to the stage.
He says: “I’m looking forward to playing these new songs. This record tells a story, so we’re working on the stage design, setlist and lighting to tell that story. We’re playing stadiums now, but I want fans to still have an intimate experience.”
SHE was 35 and in her prime when Smash Hits magazine published images of her parading the stage in a skimpy bra – and scoffed: “Calm down, grandma!”
But the cutting headline, which accompanied a review of her Girlie Show tour in 1993, did nothing to deter the uniquely stylish Madonna.
Sign up for the Showbiz newsletter
Thank you!
In a career spanning more than 40 years, Madonna became the hottest female singer in the world, selling over 400million recordsCredit: Rafael PavarottiThe Queen of Pop has faced intense backlash over her appearance through it allCredit: InstagramMadonna with her boyfriend, former footballer Akeem Morris, 29Credit: instagram
In a career spanning more than 40 years, she became the hottest female singer in the world, selling over 400million records.
But through it all, the Queen of Pop faced intense backlash over her appearance.
Critics have judged everything from her cone bra in 1990 to her Met Gala “bondage”-style outfit in 2016, when she was 57.
But now, as Madge prepares to return to the spotlight with her 15th studio album, she has done what many thought would never be possible.
The Vogue singer confirmed this week that she will release her first record in seven years this July — a sequel to her 2005 smash Confessions On A Dance Floor.
The original, inspired by disco and Eighties electropop, shifted more than 10million copies.
It featured No1 singles Hung Up and Sorry, and ushered in a new era of dance music.
Now, Confessions On A Dance Floor: Part II is promising to be a continuation of the project.
And Madonna is still not letting her age define her fashion, posing in a blue leotard, fishnets, a silver jacket and shades in a defiant photo to promote the record.
The Vogue singer confirmed she will release her first record in seven years this July — Confessions On A Dance Floor: Part IICredit: APMadonna guest DJ’s with producer Stuart PriceCredit: instagram/madonna
A music insider said: “Madonna has locked in for this project and it’s not at all what you’d expect from any other woman who is nearly 70.
“It has roots in New York house music and rave culture and her record label believes it will usher in a whole new generation of fans.
“Confessions 1 showed Madonna at her coolest and, after straying into other genres on her last few albums, this feels wonderfully authentic.”
Madge is yet to release the album’s first single, but she has been steadily building a Gen Z fanbase, who have been discovering her back catalogue.
Last month, her 1985 chart-topper Into The Groove returned to the Top 20 after going viral on TikTok.
Cruz Beckham, KSI, Aitch and Sam Thompson were among those who shared videos of themselves dancing to the song 41 years after it was a No1 hit.
Madge is yet to release the album’s first single, but she has been steadily building a Gen Z fanbase, who have been discovering her back catalogueCredit: GettySabrina Carpenter said: ‘She’s so lovely and so exactly how you expect her to be — just, like, so magnetic’Credit: Getty
And she is heavily tipped to make a live return tonight at the buzziest festival of the year alongside one of the world’s hottest young pop stars, Sabrina Carpenter, 26.
The Espresso singer will headline the second weekend of Coachella in California and has extended her set by ten minutes, further fuelling industry whispers that Madge may join her on stage.
It would be the veteran pop star’s first performance there in 20 years. She delivered a memorable set in 2006 following the release of her first Confessions album.
Sabrina idolises Madonna as a blueprint for pop music — and there are suggestions they may have collaborated on a song.
In 2024, she paid tribute to Madge by attending the MTV VMAs in a vintage strapless gown previously worn to the Oscars by her musical hero in 1991.
Sabrina said of Madonna last year: “She’s so lovely and so exactly how you expect her to be — just, like, so magnetic.”
Madonna plays an epic set at Coachella Festival 20 years agoCredit: GettyStuart Price was musical director on her 81-date Celebration Tour in 2023 and 2024Credit: Getty
Many of the current crop of pop starlets have named Madonna as their top inspiration.
Dua Lipa has said her 2020 No1 album Future Nostalgia was heavily influenced by Madge, and she worked with her on a remix of her song Levitating.
Jade Thirlwall said last year: “She is one of the best pop stars we will ever get.”
It is a sea-change from previous generations who used Madge as a verbal punching bag.
When asked to name the most overrated person in pop, Lily Allen once said: “Madonna. She might have meant something once, but I don’t know many people my age who care.”
A Smash Hits magazine headline pouring scorn on her style back in 1993Credit: Unknown
And Lady Gaga insisted she could not be compared to the megastar, explaining: “I play a lot of instruments. I write all my own music . . . I’m a producer. I’m a writer. What I do is different.”
On Wednesday, Madonna released a snippet of upcoming track I Feel So Free, which heavily samples the 1989 house tune French Kiss by Lil Louis.
The original features more than two minutes of sex noises — something which seems fitting for pop’s most notorious provocateur.
For Confessions II, Madonna has teamed up again with British producer Stuart Price, who was musical director on her 81-date Celebration Tour in 2023 and 2024.
Meanwhile, her boyfriend, former footballer Akeem Morris, 29, is regularly seen dancing and larking around with her in videos on TikTok, where her clips have been liked over 45million times.
Last month, Madonna was in Venice shooting for the second series of the Apple TV show The Studio, in which she will appear opposite Julia Garner.
But now it is full steam ahead with her music, after re-signing with Warner Records — her label for the first 24 years of her career.
Madonna said of her new album: “When Stuart Price and I first started working on this record, this was our manifesto: We must dance, celebrate and pray with our bodies . . . To rave is an art. It’s about pushing your limits and connecting to a community of like-minded people.”