ARIANA GRANDE broke down in tears on stage at what could be her final-ever concert.
The superstar, 33, sobbed as she opened up about her decision to step back from public life.
Ariana Grande has performed for the final time ahead of taking a step back from public lifeCredit: The Mega AgencyAriana was left tearful during the arena gigCredit: Supplied
Halting her final gig at London’s O2 Arena, Ariana said: “I just wanted to say thank you so much.
“This has been such an extraordinary experience.
Sign up for the Showbiz newsletter
Thank you!
“Thank you for ten beautiful London shows and 41 incredible Eternal Sunshine shows.”
Breaking down in tears, Ariana continued: “This has been one of the most beautiful extraordinary experiences of my life and I just wanted to express my gratitude without sobbing.
“It has been so special and I will cherish this experience always.
“I have loved every minute of this with you all and I just wanted to make sure I express how grateful I am.”
Signing off, she continued: “Thank you for being by my side all the way from Honeymoon Avenue to Hampsted.”
The star is stepping back from public life following the conclusion of the tourCredit: GettyThe star spoke out to the crowd ahead of her time-out from the spotlightCredit: SuppliedShe gave a poignant final message to the audienceCredit: SuppliedAriana has performed a run of 10 sold-out shows in LondonCredit: Getty
Ariana broke down in tears for a second time before performing Hate That I Made You Love Me.
The singer struggled to get her words out as she thanked everyone who has worked on the tour from hair and make up to the security.
For the final show of the tour Ariana added four songs from her new album Petal.
The singer belted out Oh Well, Like I Do and the record’s lead single Hate That I Made You Love Me.
Ari also performed Nowhere, Nobody for the first time.
During her performance of hit single Thank U, Next the star continued her recent trend of changing the words to reflect her rekindling things with dancer Ricky Alvarez.
Rather than singing “wrote some songs about Ricky, now I listen and laugh” the superstar sang: “Wrote some songs about Ricky, I’m trying to make him my last.”
Ariana’s Wicked co-star Cynthia Erivo watched her final show from the sound decks.
However, unlike on night two of the 10 London shows when she joined Ariana on stage, she opted to take a back seat and simply watch the show as a fan.
It was previously revealed that Ariana would be retreating from the public eye following the end of tonight’s run of 10 O2 Arena shows of the Eternal Sunshine Tour.
In a statement released last month, a rep for the 7 Rings singer said: “Ariana will be taking a step back from visibility after she completes the Eternal Sunshine Tour.
“She looks forward to finishing the tour and ending it on a high note, both healthily and happily, and then taking a much-deserved break from public-facing work and appearances, which have led to endless, ongoing public scrutiny.
“This tour has been a beautiful experience for her.
“She loves her fans and has loved every minute of this tour so much.”
Ariana herself later clarified that the decision had been months in the planning and was not in response to widespread concern for her health after visible weight loss over the past year.
The singer said: “It was not a reactive or impulsive thing. It is something that I have decided, a plan that I had quietly made a long time ago and it’s a decision that was made from a thoughtful and empowered place.
“And I want you to know that many things can be true at the same time.”
She added: “I heard that my fans were worried that negativity was ruining things for me, but I just have to say that could not be more the f*** opposite.
“This is not what that is. I just want to be very, very clear. Multiple things can be true at the same time.
“Boundaries need to be set.
“Human beings need a break sometimes. And also, this can be, and will continue to be, the greatest experience of my professional and creative life. So, I just wanted to make that quite plain.”
It comes a month after Ariana pulled out of making her West End debut in Sunday in the Park with George slated for next year at the Barbican.
Sammy and Jonathan were one of a number of couples whose romantic journeys were never shown on the Netflix show
18:45, 29 Aug 2026Updated 18:47, 29 Aug 2026
Sammy’s Love Is Blind UK love story never made it to air(Image: Tom Dymond/Netflix)
Love Is Blind UK’s third season saw a record number of engagements – but only a handful were shown.
The Netflix reality dating show sees 30 singles sent on a string of blind dates in the show’s pods which are designed to prevent the contestants from ever seeing each other. The only way they can meet a potential partner face to face is if they accept a marriage proposal from them.
An unprecedented number of contestants became engaged during the latest season – 14 to be precise – though just six of those love stories were shown to viewers at home.
The show’s executive producer, Nazleen Karim, previously addressed why they cut some couples on the programme but kept following others. She explained: “When there are more engagements than we can physically follow, we have to make difficult editorial choices. We’re looking for a range of different relationship journeys and stories that together capture the full experience of the experiment.
“Not being selected isn’t a reflection of the strength of a relationship – many couples continue exploring their connection once they leave the pods.”
Now, one couple who were cut from the show revealed what happened to them afterwards, and the remarkable journey they have been on since.
Tech recruiter Jonathan, 32, and wellbeing coach and entrepreneur Sammy, 31, found a connection in the pods and became engaged, but their dates, nor that all-important proposal, were ever shown.
In a tell-all Instagram post, Sammy recounted that she asked a producer to give Jonathan her number after they were told they would not be continuing on the programme, and the pair continued to date in the real world.
Content cannot be displayed without consent
Since leaving the show in August last year, they have jetted off on holiday together, met each other’s families, got a dog together named Poddy in homage to the show, and remain engaged to this day. Sammy also revealed the devastating news that the pair had suffered a silent miscarriage in June.
“We lost our baby to a silent miscarriage and honestly, we really struggled,” she shared. “Grieving whilst still living on opposite sides of the country was one of the hardest things we’ve had to face together.”
While she admitted the pair were still navigating the loss, Sammy revealed their love story still endured. She added: “We didn’t get picked to continue on Love Is Blind. At the time, that felt like the end of our story. Turns out, it was the beginning of the best bit.
“No cameras. No experiment. No guarantees. We just kept choosing each other, and now you’re finally in on the secret.”
Love Is Blind UK series three is now streaming on Netflix. A reunion special will air tomorrow night (August 30) at 9pm.
Love Is Blind UK is back on Netflix with eight fresh episodes for fans to binge watch
Jack is looking for love on the Netflix show (Image: Netflix )
Love Is Blind UK star Jack Bradshaw has spoken out about disappearing from the show without warning his fiancée.
The hit Netflix experiment is back for its third season with a fresh batch of singles hoping to find love in the famous pods. As always, the contestants go on a string dates without ever laying eyes on each other.
Once they are ready to commit to one person, they leave the pods and get engaged. From there comes a series of relationship milestones including moving in together and meeting each other’s families.
Faye soon realised that Jack’s phone location had been turned off, leaving her concerned about his whereabouts. “He’s literally vanished,” Faye said.
Jack has now explained his actions, admitting he went on a walk because he was “panicking” about formally meeting Faye’s parents later that day.
He told Tudum: “I started panicking and stressing about meeting Faye’s parents properly and being back on camera again. It felt like the walls were closing in on me. I needed to get out, disconnect, and just have some time by myself. “
The Cornwall-based star was also overwhelmed by living in the heart of Canary Wharf and needed a moment to breathe, so he turned his phone off and headed out.
“In Canary Wharf, I’m in this glass box, 43 stories up in the air,” he said.
“Can’t relax there. Go out to get fresh air and there are skyscrapers everywhere. There are cars, police cars, people. I’m walking along just stressing myself out.”
Although it felt like the right move at the time, Jack claims he felt “overwhelming guilt” when he finally turned his phone on and saw a several messages from his partner.
He said: “Faye is worried sick, and I get this overwhelming feeling of guilt about how I let her down. I wasn’t used to having somebody there who cares that much about me.”
Jack confessed: “Just seeing how one selfish decision in your mind can affect somebody…. And that’s the only way I can describe it. It was selfish. I was looking after number one.”
The first eight episodes of Love Is Blind season three are now streaming on Netflix, with the final three instalments set to air next Wednesday, August 26.
Love Is Blind: UK Season 3 is streaming on Netflix
HAYDEN Panettiere’s on-off boyfriend Brian Hickerson has broken his silence on the actress’ sudden death from a suspected overdose.
The Nashville star died on Sunday afternoon at her South Carolina Airbnb, where she was staying with Brian and his brother Zach Hickerson.
Hayden Panettiere’s on-off boyfriend Brian Hickerson has broken his silence on the actress’ sudden passingCredit: RexHayden died on Sunday at her South Carolina Airbnb from a suspected overdoseCredit: Getty
An investigation is currently ongoing into what led to the 36-year-old’s death, and the Drug Enforcement Administration has joined the team.
Brian, 37, has spoken out for the first time since the incident through his attorney, Sloan Ellis, from the Ellis Hinton law firm.
Sign up for the Showbiz newsletter
Thank you!
“Hayden’s death remains under investigation, and it is important to allow that investigation to proceed,” Brian’s attorney told The U.S. Sun on Thursday.
“As has been publicly reported, police confirmed there were no signs of foul play.”
The statement concluded, “Out of respect for Hayden’s loved ones and the ongoing investigation, there will be no further comment at this time.”
Brian was spotted on Wednesday in Greenville, South Carolina, close to where Hayden died, wearing a hat, sunglasses, and a hoodie.
He’d been keeping a low profile since his brother discovered Hayden unconscious in a chair in the living room, where she was later declared dead, per a police report obtained by The U.S. Sun.
Police said that while Zach was very emotional upon the discovery, Brian apparently didn’t shed a tear until Hayden was officially declared dead.
Most read in Entertainment
Brian also told cops that the Remember the Titans star regularly took a “bag of medication.”
All eyes have since been on Brian’s family, as more questions surface about Hayden’s unexpected passing.
Hayden’s estranged mother, Lesley Vogel, slammed Brian in an interview with NBC News on Tuesday, saying, “This person in her life that we have been trying to get rid of for quite some time was with her at her death, and that was Brian Hickerson.”
It wasn’t a secret that Hayden and Brian had a tumultuous, years-long relationship since meeting in 2018.
All eyes have been on Brian since he was with Hayden when she diedCredit: GettyBrian was arrested and jailed in 2021 for hitting Hayden with a closed fistCredit: Splash
Brian was arrested for domestic violence and served 45 days in jail in 2021 for hitting Hayden with a closed fist.
He pleaded no contest to two felony counts of injuring the former child star.
However, they appeared to have reconciled as Brian has been staying with Hayden in her Los Angeles apartment for the last two years, The U.S. Sun exclusively reported.
The Heroes star’s neighbors have also raised alarm about the pair’s relationship and were even warned by the Homeowner’s Association to call the police if they saw Brian on the property last August.
Hayden’s neighbor, Mia Terrazzas, claimed to Inside Edition that notices were distributed on the property urging residents to be wary of Brian.
Mia also said she herself even called 911 numerous times over disturbances involving Brian inside Hayden’s unit.
Hayden’s history with addiction is also of great concern, as sources claimed she sought out whippets and booze just months earlier at a Nashville hotel, despite her efforts to get clean.
Lisa Hayden-Johnson was jailed after fabricating her son Matthew’s illnesses
23:00, 19 Aug 2026Updated 23:00, 19 Aug 2026
Lisa Hayden-Johnson is defending herself years after being jailed for cruelty in a new Channel 4 series(Image: Channel 4)
Lisa Hayden-Johnson has defended her actions in a new Channel 4 documentary.
The Devon woman has spoken out for the first time since being released from prison. She was jailed in 2010 for three years and three months after admitting cruelty and perverting the course of justice.
Matthew’s supposed health battle attracted widespread media attention. The youngster went on to appear on various TV shows and was famously introduced to the Duchess of Cornwall, now Queen Camilla.
The young boy, now aged 25, was also subjected to medical interventions before doctors grew suspicious about his alleged health problems. Now, both mother and son are telling their sides of the story in new Channel 4 three-part series, Love You to Death.
A synopsis for the show states: “Young Matthew’s health problems worry medics and his mum Lisa. But when doctors’ efforts to improve Matthew’s condition don’t work, suspicions are raised and the police are called in to investigate.”
In the first episode, which aired on Wednesday (August 19), Lisa refutes the infamous ‘most evil mum’ title she earned as a result of the story.
She says: “I’ve never had the opportunity to [tell her story]. The newspaper articles are so incorrect. How can I be ‘Britain’s Most Evil Mother?'”
She goes on to add: “The only thing I was guilty of was putting my son first and fighting his battle, which is what I did. And I don’t regret that.”
Matthew, who will feature in the second episode of the series, spoke to the BBC about how it felt to hear his mother’s perspective.
He said: “It was a lot of disappointment but I think also frustration as almost two decades on, there is still a lack of accountability from her side.
“When I could see, even after two decades… she still holds the same story and believes that she did the best by me… that obviously isn’t right.” Matthew’s older sister, Laura, also speaks out in the documentary.
Love You To Death Episode 1 is streaming now on Channel 4
HAYDEN Panettiere’s estranged mother has broken her silence after the actress’s sudden death at 36.
The Nashville star was found dead in a South Carolina apartment on Sunday afternoon from a suspected overdose.
Hayden Panettiere with her mother Lesley Vogel at the InStyle/Warner Bros. after party for the 66th Annual Golden Globe Awards in January 2009Credit: Getty ImagesHayden and her estranged mother on a yacht on Sydney Harbour in March 2009Credit: Getty
Lesley Vogel spoke out about her daughter’s death and Hayden’s rekindled relationship with her ex, Brian Hickerson, who was reportedly at the scene when she died.
“This person in her life that we have been trying to get rid of for quite some time was with her at her death, and that was Brian Hickerson,” Lesley told NBC News on Tuesday.
Sign up for the Showbiz newsletter
Thank you!
“I think Hayden was an amazingly talented person in so many departments, and I think young people who grow up in the entertainment industry — it is a struggle, and it’s a very challenging industry, and it’s not unusual for them to sadly find the wrong path,” she added.
Lesley also told the outlet, “I think it becomes very difficult to be true to yourself, and I think Hayden sadly lost her way, and I wish it were different. I wish she had stayed true to herself because she had many incredible attributes.”
“I just feel that she’s with her brother and they’re at peace,” she said, speaking of Hayden’s younger brother Jansen, who died at 28 in February 2023 from an enlarged heart and aortic valve complications.
Hayden confirmed in May that she had not been in contact with her mother for some time.
“Unfortunately, we don’t have a relationship right now,” the Heroes star told Us Weekly while promoting the release of her memoir, This Is Me: A Reckoning.
“But that doesn’t mean that I don’t leave the door open for the opportunity to present itself one day. It’s hard for me to say, but I’ve chosen to be brutally honest.”
Most read in Entertainment
Hayden also discussed her difficult relationship with her mother during a sit-down with Jay Shetty on his podcast.
“Everything was business,” the former child star said earlier this year.
“I became the confidant and the assistant and the therapist and the shoulder to cry on and everything but her child.
“I said to her, ’I don’t want us to work together anymore. I just want you to be my mom.’
Hayden’s younger brother Jansen died in February 2023; the siblings posed for photos with their mother at a screening of Freestyle Releasing’s Sharkwater Extinction in January 2019Credit: GettyHayden was found dead in her South Carolina apartment on SundayCredit: APHayden had secretly rekindled her relationship with her ex-boyfriend, Brian Hickerson, who was reportedly with her at the time of her deathCredit: RexHayden’s mental health battles led to her giving up custody of her daughter, Kaya, 11, to her ex-fiancé Wladimir KlitschkoCredit: Getty
“I remember being hopeful. But I also wasn’t expecting the reaction that I got, which was, ‘You owe me.’ And that’s all she said. And she walked out.”
Lesley previously addressed the estrangement, claiming it was her choice to distance herself from her daughter.
“After 20 years of trauma, I took the advice of professionals and chose the no-contact route,” Lesley told Page Six after the release of Hayden’s memoir.
“As many parents of entertainment children [know], we are all too familiar with the painful observation of watching the self-destructive paths they sometimes choose.
“No parent hopes for this scenario; we want our children to be the best of themselves and live a peaceful, joyful life!”
Hayden had been spending more time with her off-again, on-again boyfriend, Brian, who was reportedly staying with her at the time of her death.
According to TMZ, the couple were back together but hiding their romance since Hayden’s team found their relationship “bad for business.”
Hayden had opened up about their previous split in her memoir and her other struggles, like addiction, grieving her brother’s unexpected death, as well as her severe postpartum depression.
The Remember the Titans star’s mental health battles led to her giving custody of her 11-year-old daughter, Kaya, to her ex-fiancéWladimir Klitschko.
Hayden reportedly planned to reunite with Kaya, who lives with her father in Ukraine, before her tragic death.
WLADIMIR Klitschko has broken his silence following the sudden death of his ex-fiancé Hayden Panettiere.
The beloved US actress, who was nominated for two Golden Globes, died on Sunday, her heartbroken family confirmed.
Wladimir Klitschko posted a moving tribute to his ex fiance along with a family photoCredit: Instagram / Wladimir KlitschkoThe pair were engaged in 2013 but split up in before tying the knotCredit: Shutterstock Editorial
In a moving tribute posted on Instagram, Wladimir, 50, said: “Our family is going through a time of profound shock and grief.
“The announcement of Hayden’s tragic death saddens me deeply.”
Sign up for the Showbiz newsletter
Thank you!
The retired Ukrainian boxing champion had a daughter with Hayden during their nine year on-and-off relationship.
He added: “She left this world far too soon. Hayden was, although no longer my partner, an important part of my life and the mother of our daughter, Kaya.
“To our daughter Kaya, I will always speak of her mother with respect and make sure she remembers the person she was.
“I extend my deepest condolences to Hayden’s parents, her friends, and her fans, who are also grieving today.
“Young and talented people like Hayden should not leave this world so soon.”
Hayden with ex-partner Wladimir Klitschko and their daughter KayaCredit: TwitterWladimir and his brother Vitalii Klychko after winning the WBO heavyweight belt in 2000Credit: Getty
Wladimir met Hayden in 2009 and the pair – who had a 14-year age gap – were later engaged in 2013 but split up in before tying the knot.
A serious bout of postpartum depression led to her giving up custody of her daughter, Kaya, 11, in 2018.
In an interview with parenting outlet Mome published in July, Hayden described the heart-breaking decision.
She said: “It wasn’t a decision I made lightly, nor was it a decision I even wanted to make.
“I was going through a really challenging time in my life… I knew I needed to be able to put her first so that I could get the help I needed and be the mum she needed me to be.”
The mother-of-one, who would have turned 37 on Friday, had complained of back pain in the months before her death, sources told TMZ.
Confirming the tragic news, her dad Skip Panettiere said: “It is with profound sadness that we share the tragic passing of our beloved Hayden.
“She was an incredible light and a force of nature who brought immeasurable love and joy to all who knew her – and to the millions who watched her on screen.”
Police were reportedly responding to an “incident” involving the actress when they found her, with investigations still ongoing.
Hayden had recently been dating Brian Hickerson in an on-again, off-again relationship.
US media reported both Hayden and Brian, had flown out ofLos Angeleson Saturday.
Hayden Panettiere said she had “a lot more life to live” in a final interviewCredit: Youtube/Jay Shetty PodcastHayden Panettiere was described as a ‘force of nature’ by her heartbroken dadCredit: Shutterstock Editorial
The pair were together from 2018 to 2020 when Hickerson was arrested, convicted and jailed for domestic violence against the actress.
He served only one day of a 45-day jail term and the couple reconnected in 2021.
At the time, Brian said: “We have a long history together, and the first step in my recovery as an abuser is making amends.”
Hayden, born in New York, first hit the screens as an 11-month-old child when her mum took her to star in several TV commercials.
Her first acting gig came when she was four-years-old on the American soap opera One Life to Live.
The diminutive actress would stay in the TV and film industry for her entire life.
Her film debut came at the age of nine, as the narrator and voice of Princess Dot in the 1998 animated Pixar flick A Bug’s Life.
She was nominated for a Young Artist Award and a Grammy Award on the back of the film’s box office success, which made her the fifth-youngest Grammy nominee ever.
A young Hayden Panettiere during an interview with TV host Jay Leno in 1996Credit: GettyHayden attends the grand opening of Dylan’s Candy Bar in New York City in 2001Credit: Shutterstock Editorial
Away from Hollywood, Hayden is best known for her leading roles on TV.
She starred in 73 episodes of Emmy-award winning Heroes between 2006 to 2010 as cheerleader Claire Bennet.
Hayden later earned two Golden Globe nominations as Juliette Barnes on Nashville where she featured in 128 episodes from 2012 to 2018.
Hayden also lent her voice to video games including hit series Until Dawn.
Her sudden death comes months after her candid autobiography, This Is Me: A Reckoning, detailed her experiences with postpartum depression, drug addiction and recovery.
The actress has spoken out about the most difficult time she endured while filming, recalling the scary moment on set.
For those still unaware, High Potential is a crime drama remake that sees Olson take on the role of single mother, Morgan. Not only is she juggling her hectic home life, but she has an exceptional mind.
With an unconventional knack for solving crimes, it leads her to an unusual and unstoppable partnership with a by-the-book seasoned detective. Now she is working full time with the LAPD to help them on their toughest cases.
It is based on the original Belgian French production HPI. Fans have been eagerly awaiting the third season of High Potential, which is expected to debut in early 2027.
In the meantime, Olson has not been too far away from our screens, appearing in the new season of It’s Always Sunny In Philadelphia, reprising the character of Dee Reynolds, whom she has played since it first aired back in 2006.
She also returned in her guest role for the last instalment of Hacks. Sadly, between filming this and High Potential last year, Olson’s father become seriously ill.
Vanity Fair reports that Don Olson went into hospital for surgery to repair an aortic aneurysm that was discovered. Unfortunately, there were complications from the surgery and he suffered an inflammatory response in his lungs, causing them to fill with fluid.
He was sent to intensive care for further treatment. Olson told the publication that she learned of his condition while filming High Potential.
She admitted she did something she has never done before and left the set. She said: “I literally just got in the car and drove home, called them on the way, and was kind of shut down for a little bit.”
Olson ended up flying back and forth between Oregon and Los Angeles to be alongside her family, while also trying to film two shows back to back.
More bad news followed her first day back on set for Hacks. She revealed: “Honestly, at this point, it’s a blur. I collapsed in the line producer’s arms. I said, ‘I have to go.’ And he said, ‘Go.’”
Her dad had contracted pneumonia and slipped into a coma. Doctors said that they did not expect him to make a full recovery although he regained consciousness.
It was clearly a traumatic time for the star. Looking back she said: “I’d have to stop and take phone calls and wipe away tears and come back and then try and be funny. And it felt so weird. I felt guilty, because I was legitimately having fun. That was confusing.”
Her father was cared for at home from December last year until his death in May. However, before he died, he did see his daughter’s final bow in Hacks, and now the episode will forever remain ‘very special’ as a result.
Tom Segura is finally addressing the news that he and Christina Pazsitzky are divorcing.
In July, news broke that the comedy power couple were calling it quits after nearly two decades of marriage, and last week Pazsitzky shared her feelings on the matter during an episode of “Your Mom’s House,” the wildly successful comedy podcast the two launched together in 2010. On Wednesday — a week after Pazsitzky’s episode dropped — Segura stepped in to host the show and share his side of the story.
“My first podcast here in a while,” Segura began the episode, guest co-hosted by fellow comedian Ryan Sickler. “I know that a lot of people obviously heard the news and saw last week’s episode where Christina hosted.”
Segura said although he doesn’t feel like he needs to say much on the matter, it did bother him that fans called him out with jabs like, “I can’t believe you would make her go address this alone.” Segura said that assumption couldn’t be further from the truth and that the former couple had been recording separate episodes since they split earlier this year.
“Everything that people know is not new to us,” he said. “It’s been many, many months.”
Last week, Pazsitzky cried during what she dubbed the “divorce episode” of “Your Mom’s House” and told guest co-host Duncan Trussell that the pair tried to work it out for several years for the sake of their children and family. “We gave it all we could, but we just couldn’t work things out,” she said. “We are no longer a couple.”
Segura said Pazsitzky’s episode happened to be the first after TMZ caught wind that the pair had split, so she addressed it first. “It was never like, ‘Hey, you go handle this.’ It was just the the timing … and we both decided to record separately.”
Segura said the split had been a long and horrible experience. “It’s, emotionally, a roller coaster. Your emotions change often many times in a day. If anyone’s ever been through it, you don’t feel the same all the time, and it’s really tough on you. Like personally, it’s really tough.
“Having it be public is awful,” he continued, adding that the former couple hoped to keep the high-profile split private. “It’s a private matter.”
Segura continued that he’s not the type of guy who’s an “open book” with his personal life, and that he understands the public’s interest in their divorce, whether they are trolls or heartbroken fans. “I totally get it,” he said. “I also wanted to reiterate that we’re not combative. We talk every day. I support Christina and everything she does. She supports me, and our focus, as you would imagine, is just on our children. We’re just trying to provide the best life we can for them, and we’re trying to take care of them.”
The comedian, who has previously used his marriage as source material in his stand-up comedy, told listeners that he wouldn’t be doing interviews, podcasts or press about the split and planned to focus on his work and co-parenting with Pazsitzky. “This is me addressing what it is and how it’s been, and it’s been terrible. And I don’t feel like I need to keep talking about this. … As disappointing as it is, it is what it is.”
Los Angeles police Officer Daniel Flores may have broken the law when he secretly recorded his colleagues making ugly, unacceptable comments that were variously racist, homophobic, misogynistic or otherwise gross and unprofessional at best.
So L.A. County Dist. Atty. Nathan Hochman is right to take this, or any, violation of the law by a badge-wearing member of our police force seriously, no matter what Flores’ intent was.
But Monday, Flores was arraigned on 16 felony counts that could lock him up in state prison for 13 years (he pleaded not guilty).
That court hearing was preceded by an unusual and disturbing summary of the case filed with the court by Hochman. It seemed like an inappropriate attempt to smear Flores as a money-grubber with a convoluted plan to sue taxpayers into a sweet retirement (as opposed to intending to expose misconduct), while simultaneously giving an aw-shucks, it-was-all-in-good-fun defense of the ugly commentary of the recorded officers.
Regardless of what Hochman’s intent is in throwing the book at Flores, the result is one that will haunt this city for years to come: a police force in which the officers are clear that if you rat out the cops for misconduct, you get what you get.
“The message to everyone in the police department is keep your mouth shut,” said David A. Harris, a law professor at University of Pittsburgh and an expert on police misconduct. “You cannot stand up for principle or even for the policy of the police department, except at the risk of your own career and your own well-being, and perhaps your freedom.”
Hochman spoke with me for nearly an hour about his reasons for what many, myself included, see as his prosecutorial overreach in this case. Before I tell you the reasons why I think Hochman has it wrong — dangerously wrong — in the decision to charge Flores’ so harshly, I’ll tell you where we agree.
Cops, we concur, should not call women “bitches.” They also should not call women “rapeable,” even if, as Hochman’s filing assures us, “the use of the phrase ‘rape’ was not in a sexual context.”
I am not sure what the nonsexual context of rape is, but OK.
Cops should not make fun of, in no particular order, people with disabilities; candidates applying for jobs; co-workers; Asian people; Hispanic people; or people who may be overweight — as the officers in this case allegedly did.
“These comments are deplorable. They’re despicable. They’re racist. They’re homophobic. They’re sexist,” Hochman told me. “There’s no place in our society for them, and they should be punished.”
So Hochman and I agree that Flores may have broken the law, and that the comments of his fellow officers are unacceptable.
And now the roads diverge.
Because faced with those competing truths, Hochman could have used prosecutorial discretion — the art of tempering the law with the mores and ethics of the community.
He could have used that discretion to cut Flores a break, charge him at a lower misdemeanor level or not at all, and put the focus where it belongs — on the officers who disgraced their badge with their behavior, and what is seemingly a culture of disrespect and degradation within the unit charged with choosing the next generation of officers.
These are the officers charged with recruiting the officers of the future, so the stakes here are high. This is misconduct that the people of L.A. need to know about, because if these officers are so casual in their hateful comments, can we trust their judgment on hiring?
“On one hand, being a whistleblower doesn’t give a person the right to violate the law,” said Erwin Chemerinsky, the dean of UC Berkeley’s law school, who did an investigation on police culture in the LAPD in 2000 in the wake of the Rampart scandal. “On the other hand, I would hope that the district attorney would take context into account. And 16 felony charges seems really excessive.”
LAPD Officer Daniel Flores, left, listens as his attorney Alan Jackson speaks to reporters Monday.
(Libor Jany / Los Angeles Times)
But Hochman argues that a “message has to be sent” because it’s a police officer who broke the law.
“If you don’t hold police officers accountable, it’s very hard to hold anybody accountable,” Hochman said. “I believe that no, we’re not going to let the ends justify the means, even if the ends may be laudable, like exposing bigotry, because it leads us down a very slippery slope.”
Hochman said Flores simply could have taken notes on the inappropriate comments and turned them in to superiors or the independent inspector general, which strikes me as either sweetly naive or disingenuous.
“The officer would be shunned; his career would be over, and he would probably find himself on the receiving end of some kind of retaliation,” Harris, the law professor, said of the likely outcome of that plan.
Chemerinsky said retaliation against whistleblowers has long been a part of the culture of the department. Make a complaint, his report in 2000 found, and an officer might get “freeway therapy,” transferred to someplace far from where they lived to send a message, or even find themselves without backup in a dangerous situation.
This decision to treat Flores so harshly, Chemerinsky said, comes off as “part of that long history of LAPD trying to very much crack down on whistleblowing.”
Hochman told me that he wants to make it “crystal clear” that “nothing in this prosecution should be read that we are in any way trying to chill whistleblowers.”
He added that he did use discretion.
“I hope you note in your article that the district attorney could have brought 122 felony charges, or 122 misdemeanors, or some combination of felonies and misdemeanors up to 122,” Hochman said.
Flores made 122 total recordings of 16 people. Hochman charged on the number of people recorded, not the number of recordings, he pointed out.
So sure, we can count that as discretion, I guess?
This is where Hochman has his messages dangerously backward. Sure, hold Flores reasonably accountable for taking matters into his own hands, if he broke the law in doing so. Certainly, Flores knew there would be consequences to his actions.
But that Hochman is trying to frame this as a fair and reasonable prosecution, while protecting the officers who made the comments by giving us their weak-sauce excuses about having no ill intent, does not provide this city the justice it expects and deserves.
Hochman, you may recall, replaced George Gascón, a prosecutor who was accused of forcing his own values on the city.
Now, Hochman seems to be doing the same with his heavy-handed approach to Flores.
Hammering on Flores does not reflect the values of the majority of the Los Angeles community that wants a police force in which integrity and respect are fundamental, impunity is the outcast, and whistleblowers aren’t attacked, even if it turns out their motives aren’t pure.
Personally, I don’t care what Flores’ intent was in making the recordings. I don’t care if the officers caught on tape didn’t intend to offend, and I don’t care what Hochman intends the message to be with his vast over-charging of Flores.
I care about the result: a city in which misogyny and racism are just locker room talk, but breaking the blue wall of silence is a serious crime.
A TV boss has broken his silence on Ariana Grande quitting a hit drama show – after revealing her plan to step back from public lifeCredit: GettyAriana was originally annouced to be on series 13 of American Horror Story but she later exited the project to prioritise her Eternal Sunshine tourCredit: Reuters
This comes at the same time she revealed she would be stepping back from fame at the end of her tour.
US screenwriter Ryan Murphy explained that he and the singer were great friendsCredit: EPAAriana told Ryan at the time that there might be scheduling issuesCredit: Getty – Contributor
Ryan also revealed that he welcomed the star to appear in another season which she gladly accepted.
He added: “You have to be respectful. Who is busier than Ariana Grande? No one. She had told me at the time, ‘I have this album that’s dropping.’ It was really, truly a scheduling conflict.”
Ryan also revealed that Ariana is a big fan of horror and did Scream Queens for him and explained that he would always want to work with her.
He said: “I love her, and I support her. It was a very big swing, but I might bring that back for another season, per Ariana’s availability. I think the world of her.”