Shocking

BBC iPlayer quietly adds ‘absolutely harrowing’ true crime doc on ‘most shocking’ case

Survivor Bex Williams recounts her fight to escape the blaze that killed her boyfriend as police find themselves facing a murder investigation

The new episodes have been branded a “harrowing” watch.

BBC iPlayer has quietly added two new episodes of a powerful documentary series, this time plunging viewers into a fatal blaze.

Murder Case is a documentary series by BBC Scotland that takes viewers into some of the most complex and shocking investigations, from the disappearance of Julie Reilly and the killing of Stephen Wallace.

Capturing viewers’ attention for its raw and unprecedented access, the documentary series has brought in huge praise from viewers.

One person previously praised on IMDb: “A fascinating, brilliantly constructed documentary series exploring the work of the Scottish police and the impact of brutal crimes on victims and their families.”

Another admitted: “One of the best true crime documentaries I’ve watched”, as a third penned on social media: “Absolutely shocking stuff.”

Now, two new episodes have been added to BBC iPlayer, titled Fire in the Suburbs. Bex Williams has shared her account of the fire that killed her boyfriend Cameron Logan in the new two-part BBC documentary, marking the first time she has told her story in full.

Cameron, a 23-year-old university student, and Bex, then 24, had been celebrating New Year’s Eve in 2016 before returning to the house. In the early hours, they woke to find their bed on fire, with flames quickly spreading through the room.

Bex crawled through smoke and flames as she tried to get out. The programme’s synopsis describes what happened next: “In a remarkable act of ingenuity, she opens the freezer and puts her head in, just before losing consciousness.”

Cameron’s parents escaped with minor injuries, while Bex was pulled to safety and taken to hospital. Cameron did not survive.

Ensure our latest TV stories always appear at the top of your Google Search by making us a Preferred Source. Click here to activate or add us as Preferred Source in your Google search settings.

His older brother Blair returned home to find the house ablaze, with firefighters and police already at the scene. The official synopsis continues: “Once the fire is brought under control, detectives and forensic experts begin to examine the scene.

“What initially appears to be a devastating house fire soon takes a sinister turn. Inside the property, investigators discover the unmistakable smell of petrol, and Cameron’s mother says she saw a masked figure throw something into the living room where Cameron and Bex were sleeping, before fleeing the property.”

With Bex fighting for her life in intensive care and no clear motive, officers had to piece together the evidence and establish who was responsible.

The two episodes follow that investigation alongside Bex’s account of the night, reports Glasgow Live. Murder Case first aired in 2019 and follows Police Scotland’s Major Investigation Teams as they work on complex cases.

The BBC Scotland series gives viewers a behind-the-scenes look at how detectives pursue evidence and seek justice.

The latest instalment has already prompted emotional responses from viewers. One described it as a “Good watch but very sad.” Another wrote: “Just finished this, just unbelievable. Heartbreaking.”

A true crime enthusiast discussing the documentary on TikTok warned of “sensitive content”, saying: “As you can imagine it is absolutely harrowing, but that is not the most shocking part of this story. The most shocking part is the police investigation and what they uncover.”

BBC Scotland Commissioning Executive, David Harron, previously said of the series: “Murder Case is a powerful documentary series that we knew would resonate with audiences given the unique access the production team secured and the insight it was able to give to the work of this incredible team.”

Murder Case: Fire in the Suburbs is available to stream on BBC iPlayer. It airs on BBC Scotland on November 17 and on BBC Two on November 18 at 9pm.

Murder Case can be streamed on BBC iPlayer

Source link

This City is Ours season 2 ending explained from major deaths to shocking twist

This City is Ours left fans fuming over one character as the intense gang drama came to an end

This City is Ours viewers were not happy after a major twist in the season two finale.

The hit series returned to BBC One for the final episode of season two and it revealed the ultimate fates of the show’s main antagonists including Felipe (played by Álvaro Morte) and Ozzie Thompson (Shaun Evans). Meanwhile, Michael Kavanagh (James Nelson-Joyce) was left completely isolated and devastated as his relationship with Diana (Hannah Onslow) took a dark turn.

The Liverpool-based drama, which has already been renewed for a third season, has left fans on the edge of their seats as they have been teased with plenty of twists, for example, the fate of fan-favourite Banksey (Mike Noble). Also, following the death of one of the show’s kingpins, Ronnie (Sean Bean), viewers were eager to find out what would become of the Phelan clan.

Here is all you need to know about what happened at the end of This City is Ours season 2.

Michael is in charge of the Phelan firm

After killing Ronnie in a shocking twist, Michael’s decision ultimately led to the outcome he wanted, as Elaine (Julie Graham) made him head of the Phelan firm. Worried that Ronnie would favour his son Jamie (Jack McMullen) regarding any decisions about leadership, Michael decided to remove Ronnie from the picture altogether if he were to stand a chance at becoming his successor.

In the finale, Elaine welcomed Michael back into the Phelan firm, recognising he would be crucial in digging them out of trouble. He and Banksey took care of

Ozzie Thompson, who appeared to be the orchestrator of the Phelans’ painful journey in season two.

However, Michael is not out of the woods yet, as Elaine assured Jamie that their alliance with Michael was strictly temporary, and they would avenge Ronnie’s death once the family business was back in order.

Felipe and Ozzie die

New antagonist Felipe, who had held Diana captive at the start of the season, brought his own death upon himself in a surprising twist, when he deliberately impaled himself on Diana’s knife. Wanting to share some final words with Michael, he made sure he would live long enough to reveal that his plan was orchestrated all along to bring out Michael’s true nature.

He revealed Michael had once killed his lover Luis, in a show of loyalty to Felipe’s brother Ricardo (Daniel Cerqueira), and Felipe still held a grudge. Knowing Michael wanted him dead too, he knew his ultimate plan would work out, which was to rip the one thing Michael cared most about away from him.

He knew Diana yearned for a normal life away from the world of crime, and needed to prove that Michael could never give her what she wanted. In his final breaths, Felipe warned Michael “Welcome to winter”, foreseeing Diana would see him for the evil person he really was and that he would spend the rest of his life in isolation.

Ensure our latest TV stories always appear at the top of your Google Search by making us a Preferred Source. Click here to activate or add us as Preferred Source in your Google search settings

Diana leaves Michael

Diana officially ended her relationship with Michael at the end of the season, which is exactly what Felipe had hoped would happen. However, she could not bring herself to do it personally and instead sent her mother, Lesley (Leanne Best), to deliver the message.

Lesley slammed Michael for seemingly choosing a life of crime over her daughter and warned him to steer clear, going as far as insinuating there would be fatal consequences if he refused. While it clearly broke his heart, Michael respected Diana’s decision, but fans will have to wait and see whether they end up rekindling their relationship in season three.

Fans who have already watched the finale on BBC iPlayer took to X to say the same thing, feeling Diana was well aware of what she was getting herself into. One said: “Diana has done my head in in S2. You’re going out with the head of an OCG, you knew what you were signing up for. Don’t take her back Michael Kav-a-nagh”

Another added: “Diana annoys me in this city of ours because she KNEW what she was signing up for getting with Michael??? #thiscityisours” A third commented: “Diana nonstop moaning like she didn’t know what she was signing up for in dating Michael. Ya wanted the lifestyle, put up with what comes with it.”

However, some enjoyed their relationship journey, with one fan sharing: “#thiscityisours Absolutely outstanding series. Every single actor was brilliant, & a real twist at the end. How refreshing to see the love between Diana & Michael portrayed in a very touching & affectionate way, instead of the obligatory sex scenes. Just an amazing drama.”

This City is Ours is on BBC iPlayer

Source link

‘Shocking’ new series dubbed ‘not for the faint hearted’ drops today

The brand new series is not to be missed as it promises ‘raw testimony and shocking footage’

A raw new documentary series following officers who put themselves into harms way is set to be released, and it’s coming sooner than you think.

With fresh releases landing on Channel 5 such as Police Suspect No.1 and Forensics: Murder Scene, the broadcaster has delivered once more, bringing a series that true crime fans will not want to miss.

With the first episode airing tonight (Wednesday, November 11) at 8pm, At War With Next Door plunges viewers into explosive neighbour disputes and those who are “living in a nightmare”.

It will explores the unpredictable and shocking feuds between neighbours over issues such as noise, anti-social behaviour and fly-tipping as it takes viewers across the UK.

An official synopsis has teased: “One third of Brits admit to an ongoing row with next door. Shockingly, councils across the UK receive a neighbour complaint every 70 seconds.

“Everyone should feel safe in their own home, but many don’t… and are living in a nightmare instead. This series has exclusive access to the battles raging behind Britain’s front doors, as people across the country face off with neighbours from hell.

“From noisy pets to wonky sheds, from creepy neighbours spying on your every move, to music blaring every hour day and night, we meet the people pushed to breaking point by those next door. With raw testimony and shocking footage, this series is not for the faint-hearted.”

Ensure our latest TV stories always appear at the top of your Google Search by making us a Preferred Source. Click here to activate or add us as Preferred Source in your Google search settings.

Tonight’s episode will plunge viewers into a huge dispute when a drunk woman in a downstairs flat becomes abusive. Her infatuation with her neighbour tips over the edge, as viewers will also see a “creepy resident who starts to steal a young mother’s used sanitary products from her outdoor bin, and a dispute over an unwanted shed turns violent”.

The synopsis continues: “We’re also behind the scenes of Brent Council, in one of London’s busiest and most multicultural areas. We follow the enforcement officers on the frontline against anti-social neighbours, putting themselves in harm’s way to keep neighbour disputes under control.

“This week, they’re tackling a noisy shisha bar, which is driving local residents mad. These are the stories of the most shocking neighbour disputes across the UK.”

With around four episodes expected in total, new instalments will air every Wednesday, taking over the 8pm slot – and already true crime fans say it’s one not to be missed.

Taking to social media, one enthusiast admitted: “At war with the neighbours will probably be like nightmare neighbour next door it used to be on Channel 5 it was so good it finished years ago.” Another stated: “Loving Channel 5 for true crime.”

At War with Next Door airs tonight at 8pm on Channel 5. Episodes can also be streamed online

Source link

‘The Gilded Age’ boss breaks down that shocking hookup, traumatic labor

While real-world tech mogul Elon Musk suffered a major setback this week after pouring more than $200 million into Texas Republican campaigns that lost to protect his business empire, over on HBO’s “The Gilded Age,” robber baron George Russell is fighting tooth and nail against looming federal regulations to save his.

The period drama returned Sunday with its fourth season. After leaving George (Morgan Spector) at a major turning point in Season 3 — seemingly done with his marriage following Bertha‘s (Carrie Coon) forced engineering of their daughter‘s marriage, as well as his own survival of a near-fatal shooting — the couple is still at odds. As the new season picks up, George unravels under the looming threat of anti-monopoly laws targeting his industrial empire. And that’s just part of all the drama and fun that made the episode the show’s most-watched premiere yet, averaging nearly 4 million viewers across platforms, according to the cabler/streamer. Season 4 promises more tension as the Russells try to maintain their wealth and status while Agnes van Rhijn (Christine Baranski) tries to regain her position, all while the show’s various relationships face challenges, ultimatums or bittersweet developments. Ahead of this week’s second episode, I spoke with Sonja Warfield, who is co-showrunner of the series alongside creator Julian Fellowes, about how Season 4 kicks off — including that unexpected cameo from David Letterman and Matt Damon.

You’re reading the Screen Gab newsletter

Sign up to get recommendations for the TV shows and streaming movies you can’t miss, plus exclusive interviews with the talent behind your favorite titles, in your inbox every Friday.

Also in this week’s Screen Gab, our writers recommend a new stand-up special from everyone’s favorite sitcom principal and a sports drama chronicling the life of Muhammad Ali. — Yvonne Villarreal

Turn on

Recommendations from the film and TV experts at The Times

A woman in a black lace top and black leather pants holds a microphone in front of an orange backdrop

Janelle James at the Vic Theatre in Chicago, where her Netflix comedy special was filmed.

(Elizabeth Sisson / Netflix )

“Janelle James: How Romantic” (Netflix)

Among the many gifts “Abbott Elementary” showered upon the culture was bringing Janelle James to national prominence. As work-averse principal Ava Coleman — a selfish, insulting character one is always delighted to see — she is as attractive as she is difficult. And as the show has gone on, the actor has found layers to play, including hints of a kind of existential melancholy. James began in stand-up — her biggest brush with fame was touring with Chris Rock in 2017 — and now she’s headlining her own, first hourlong special, which debuts Tuesday on the streamer and was filmed at Chicago’s Vic Theatre. Hang on through an opening salvo of political jokes that elapsed time and Tuesday’s election results have rendered stale (Rudy Giuliani, anybody? Joe Biden?) as James, laughing and dancing, unwinds into her real material — spending 24 hours in labor, the problems and perks of being suddenly famous, men and how they are, having money with a poor person’s mind. Of the power of comedy (and being on a hit sitcom) to unite a diverse audience, she says, “There’s one of everything in here. … We can all be in here and share a laugh, then everyone goes back to their respective neighborhoods, never to speak again. But for a small moment in time we were all friends. Because of me. So that’s nice.” — Robert Lloyd

Behind the red ropes of a boxing ring, a shirtless man stands with his gloved hands raised in the air

Jaalen Best as Muhammad Ali in Prime Video’s “The Greatest.”

(Brooke Palmer / Prime)

“The Greatest” (Prime Video)

The multitude of projects about Muhammad Ali just received a new entry with Prime Video’s limited series “The Greatest,” starring newcomer Jaalen Best as the legendary boxer. The project traces Ali’s breakthrough as a gold medal boxer through his brutal battle with Sonny Liston. Viewers looking for a companion piece to the drama can check out Ken Burns’ 2021 epic documentary “Muhammad Ali.” Burns called the four-part miniseries an extensive look at a “man who may be the most iconic figure of the 20th century.” The filmmaker added that Ali was also a “very complex, dynamic man” who had an immeasurable impact stretched into politics, culture and religion.” — Greg Braxton

Guest spot

A weekly chat with actors, writers, directors and more about what they’re working on — and what they’re watching

A man and a woman in late 19th-century attire lock hands in front of an ornate fireplace

Morgan Spector and Carrie Coon in Season 4 of “The Gilded Age.”

(Karolina Wojtasik / HBO)

Clocks have rolled back and “The Gilded Age” Sundays have returned — the perfect couch rotting combo for fall. Lingering crises and fresh new scandals collide in Season 4 as our favorite New York elite navigate a fracturing power marriage, perilous childbirth, a horse-carriage breakdown that ignites a night of forbidden passion, and a titan‘s struggle to maintain his empire. Even Jack’s new invention, the electric mixer, couldn’t whip up a more delicious start. Episode 2 airs Sunday on HBO and will stream on HBO Max. I spoke with Sonja Warfield, the co-showrunner of the drama, about the premiere, that David Letterman and Matt Damon cameo and what’s ahead this season. — Y.V.

You said you were looking at social media a bit after the premiere. What stood out to you about what fans were responding to?

Marian. Someone had a lot of thoughts about some of Marian’s costumes. But then I read something about Marian and Larry having sex, and they don’t want to hear about her complaining about him this season — something like, “She just needs to go over there to his house and get her ring back.”

It’s been interesting to see the conversation around Marian’s freak-out the morning after she had sex with Larry — and the ramifications of premarital sex at that time.

Louisa [Jacobson, who plays Marian] did an amazing job conveying the gravity of the transgression; it just was all over her face. And Harry’s reaction, because he’s kind of surprised. They just had this roll in the hay, but it transmits to him as well. So really, kudos to Louisa for selling that. Wonderful actors like Louisa Jacobson help the viewer along in their understanding that this is about the worst thing that you can do, and then we have the scene afterwards. That walk of shame back and the aunts even say, “Oh, it was better that you took a cab because the impropriety of that.”

We also see Gladys survive this traumatic, life-threatening breach birth, ultimately welcoming a baby boy. Some of us have PTSD from Lady Sybil’s death in “Downton Abbey” and were very nervous about where it was going.

One of the first things I said to Julian when we first started working together was, “I might never forgive you for what you did to Lady Sybil.” I remember every frame of what Lady Sybil went through. … We wanted to make sure that [“The Gilded Age”] was different, so we worked closely with a doctor who specializes in Victorian medicine to figure out how we can make it traumatic, her life is salvaged, but she’s forever changed. It’s women’s health. There’s still more questions than answers, and especially back then when they had not even surfaced. Maternal mortality rate has been lowered in recent years in America. It’s real jeopardy, and it happens all the time and every day.

Women’s health and decisions surrounding it are not the only timely modern parallel. Something that looms large is wealthy business titans trying to exert profound, direct influence over American politics and policies. How was it to dig into that history this season, given the current real-world backdrop?

As we got the research in, and we started having conversations with Dr. Dunbar [Erica Armstong Dunbar is a co-executive producer and lead historical consultant on the series], it became abundantly clear that the reason why there have been so many regulations in business is because of the Gilded Age. We’re just right back where we started. I love this argument that is being used today that was being used back then, which is “let us regulate our ourselves.” That’s ridiculous. They changed America, and brought in wealth and industry and the railroad and all of that; at the same time, it has to be regulated. They cannot regulate themselves. Greed is one of the seven deadly sins.

Two women in late 19th-century attire smile while in conversation

Audra McDonald, left, and Denée Benton in “The Gilded Age.”

(Karolina Wojtasik / HBO)

Were you nervous about having this plot about anti-monopoly legislation or how it would be received by studio brass, given the Paramount and Warner Bros. merger?

It was not in my mind because it is the real history. We are being historically accurate.

There is a moment eight minutes into the premiere episode that, if you blinked, you missed it: David Letterman and Matt Damon made cameos as background actors. Apparently, David has long wanted to be a background actor, and this stunt was filmed as a field segment for the new season of his Netflix interview show; Damon got his start as a background actor. Were you in disbelief when you heard about this request?

I am a huge David Letterman fan. When I heard that there was a possibility that I could meet David Letterman, I was ecstatic and really kind of selfish. We shoot tandem sets, so there are two sets going at a time. My mandate was, “I’m on the David Letterman set that day. Take me there.” All the way in Long Island. I had an event that night. I didn’t care. I waited for David.

Forget Matt Damon.

What was so funny was that my dad is a huge Matt Damon fan, and whilst I was awaiting David Letterman, I had an audience with Matt Damon, who is the most lovely, kind person ever. So empathetic and gracious and wonderful, and game whatever they had cooking on Letterman’s show. Then I met David Letterman. It was an absolute blast. I was like, “This is a the best day at work in a long time.” It all started because someone on our staff was friends with someone on David Letterman’s show.

We see them casually crossing the street. Was it hard to decide what scene to plop them into?

It was really about scheduling. And what would be the least conspicuous because David Letterman does have that long beard. We held on to it for so long. We shot that back in May.

I want all good things for Peggy, in life, love and career. Her wedding to William is on the horizon. What did you want out of that moment for her?

Well, once I knew we had a bigger budget, I wanted all of it too. I really do think we deliver. I want to be mindful here. The location of where she gets married is exquisitely beautiful. We enter the wedding and the marriage with trepidation because there is real conflict, inherent conflict with this family in the form of Elizabeth Kirkland, played by the incredible Felicia Rashad. I think all weddings are fraught because you’re bringing together these different factions, and people want different things and have ideas and dreams. I think Peggy’s wedding delivers on all fronts. I think it delivers in terms of dramatic tension. I think it delivers in terms of set decoration. It delivers in terms of costume and, of course, performances and direction. I can’t wait for the audience to watch it and then watch it again. Accompanying the wedding will be some beautiful photography done by the Tyler Twins. Their work is really just exquisite, and I’m excited for the world to see all this. We’ve been holding all of this in.

Peggy and William are at the dawn of their relationship, just as Bertha and George are navigating a major stress point in their union.

Marriage is a journey. I’ve been married and divorced, and I just remember my dad’s advice early on was that there are always going to be these trials, and if you can make your way through them and end up together, you will be stronger for it. For Bertha and George, who’ve been married for many years now — he didn’t make a lot of money when they were first together, and now they they’re in this place of extreme wealth, and their lives have changed. And now he is going through something that couldn’t have been predicted. And Bertha rides for her husband. There are times when couples can go their separate ways, and, like my dad said, if you can find your way back together through the storm, and you’ve weathered it together, you’re stronger. I want that for Peggy and William. They want a Bertha-George marriage — if Bertha and George make it through.

I really worry about Agnes’ stress levels this season. I don’t think it’s a spoiler to say that. Later in the season, she delivers one line — “That article was poppycock!” — in a way that will live in my head as a GIF forever.

I even said something to Christine during the season — “We’re really putting you through it this season.” I love it, and she loved it too. She had a ball, and especially in Episode 3, which I got to write with Julian. I loved writing some of that dialogue because she just has so many highs and lows throughout the season, and it was like a masterclass for me to watch Christine go from the highest high to the lowest low. She wants revenge; she is out for blood because someone is attempting to take away her opportunities. It was delicious, and I’m glad that you liked it, and I hope the greater audience enjoyed it.

Is there a moment coming up from Episode 2 that you’re excited for people to see?

I’m excited for people to see more of the Black elite in Newport.

What’s the film or TV show that you’re recommending to everyone right now?

Well, I’m behind, but I love “Nobody Wants This” [Netflix]. I have not been able to watch all of it; we had a premiere for “The Gilded Age” and lots of things going on. But I love that show. I got to meet the whole cast at the Emmys. I’m a free advertisement for that show.

ICYMI

Must-read stories you might have missed

Source link

‘Gentle Monster’ review: A shocking revelation destroys a family

It takes frighteningly little to destroy a happy family. So much love, so much joy, so much shared history can be erased by one terrible act or the discovery of something rotten that had been festering undetected. Austrian filmmaker Marie Kreutzer explores the unimaginable in “Gentle Monster,” in which a celebrated concert pianist learns that her husband and the father of her son might be involved in child pornography. Instantly, her life shatters, the pieces so scattered she may never be able to pick them all up.

Léa Seydoux plays Lucy, a musician who brings an element of social commentary to her avant-garde live performances, delivering ethereal covers of emphatic love songs written by men — such as Bryan Adams’ “(Everything I Do) I Do It for You” — to interrogate that gender’s general discomfort with emotions. It’s an important early clue into Kreutzer’s larger aims, but first the writer-director establishes Lucy’s endearing rapport with her sensitive husband Philip (Laurence Rupp) and their pre-tween son Johnny (Malo Blanchet). Having recently moved to the German countryside after living in Munich, they’re adjusting to a quieter existence with fewer neighbors but less-reliable cell service. Lucy and Philip’s sex life remains robust and Johnny enjoys the extra outdoor space. Nothing’s ever perfect, but all seems well enough.

Yet when the police arrive unannounced one morning, Philip isn’t surprised. Led by Elsa (Jella Haase), the authorities inform him they need to confiscate his computers and hard drives. He offers no resistance, quickly getting on the phone to his lawyer. Lucy comes downstairs, baffled by what’s going on as he’s taken away. When she later visits the police station to get more information, she’s directed to the second floor. That’s when Lucy realizes the horrible truth: That’s the floor assigned to the crime unit specializing in stopping sexualized violence against children. Philip, the love of her life, has been accused of storing and sharing child pornography.

As Philip awaits trial at home, Lucy processes the shock, too smart to believe this is all some awful misunderstanding. Hurriedly packing a bag, she drives off with Johnny, the two of them moving in with her regal, chilly mother Eloise (Catherine Deneuve), although Lucy does not tell her why she’s left Philip. (The judgy Eloise, herself a musician, smugly assumes that her daughter figured out that having a family is death for an artist.) Philip repeatedly calls Lucy, hoping to explain himself, but she now cannot trust anything he says. Seydoux keeps her character’s storm of emotions intriguingly opaque. Shame, disgust, anger, sadness and confusion equally course through Lucy, who starts wondering about the extent of Philip’s criminality. Did he ever abuse their son?

Kreutzer, whose 2022 drama “Corsage” starred Vicky Krieps as a rebellious 19th century empress, explores Lucy’s odyssey as she grapples with the dawning fact that she long shared a bed with a pedophile. But “Gentle Monster” eventually introduces a parallel storyline involving Elsa, the investigator. When she’s not cracking down on child pornographers — grim work that she nonetheless takes great pride in — she’s minding her aging father, Hermann (Sylvester Groth), who is experiencing severe cognitive decline. His live-in nurse Natalia (Patrycja Ziółkowska) tells Elsa that he tried to sexually assault her, which upsets Elsa but also puts her in a bind: Natalia is the only care worker Hermann has actually gotten along with. Elsa abhors his behavior but she desperately wants Natalia to stay, frantically assuring her that she’ll get him to stop.

Although both plotlines concern predatory men, “Gentle Monster” expands its thematic scope to more broadly discuss the emotional labor that women are forced to perform. Philip’s rich parents insist their son couldn’t have done anything wrong, while Elsa’s absent brother leaves her to figure out what to do about their ailing father. In their own ways, Lucy and Elsa shoulder a significant burden that has been imposed on them by someone they love, their devotion now being exploited. And in both cases, there is a societal expectation that it’s their duty to be a solo support system — Lucy as a mother and wife, Elsa as a daughter. As accomplished as these two women are, ultimately they’re reduced to being nurturers and caregivers.

Unfortunately, much like Lucy’s stilted deconstruction of male love songs, “Gentle Monster” ends up a little too intellectual for its own good, its ideas more interesting to mull over than to feel deeply. In addition, there’s a nagging narrative tidiness to Lucy’s and Elsa’s stories so conveniently echoing each other. And as formidable as Seydoux can be, the character isn’t so much heartbreakingly conflicted as she is oddly muddled and underdeveloped. Kreutzer does not fully succeed in elucidating how women are imperiled by sexual predators — even when they are not the ones directly affected — but her uneven film ripples with pain. Lucy’s behavior may be frustratingly inconsistent, but many viewers will recognize the immeasurable suffering that drives it.

‘Gentle Monster’

In German and English, with subtitles

Rated: R, for sexuality, graphic nudity and some language

Running time: 1 hour, 54 minutes

Playing: Opens Friday, Oct. 30 in limited release

Source link