SHE described her stint on Dragons’ Den as the “biggest and the most public rejection” ever – but Zara Saleem has had the last laugh.
The 37-year-old mum-of-two, who quit her underpaid £27k-a-year job, now has a business worth £5 million – and she started it all with just £500 at her kitchen table.
13
A savvy businesswoman has revealed all on how she went from a teacher earning £27,000 a year to owning a business worth £5 millionCredit: Delhicious
13
Zara Saleem runs Delhicious alongside her husband and co-founder Zak Ismail, 36Credit: Delhicious
But things haven’t all been smooth sailing for Zara, who has two daughters, aged eight and seven and her thriving beauty brand, Delhicious.
Not only did she deal with a huge plummet in sales during the coronavirus lockdown, but she’s also been faced with numerous rejections by top high-street retailers too.
However, now sales are flying for the award-winning skincare brand, which is approved by dermatologists and clinically tested.
Opening up on her business journey, Zara exclusively tells us: “I had no money when I started – we had no more than £500.
“We started with just buying a small batch of ingredients and a tiny bit of packaging. Everything else that we could do for free, we did for free, including making the website.
“The first year of revenue was very low. It was around £50,000 in year one. But now, we’ve made over £5 million since we launched.
“We’ve sold over 100,000 bottles of hair oil – we sold 10,000 bottles in three days.
“We are currently on track to make between £2 and £3 million this year and are hoping to scale the business to £8 million in the next two to three years.”
Making products in the kitchen
It was when Zara found herself having to mark up to 150 school books a day that she realised being an “underpaid” teacher was no longer for her.
And it was when Zara, who is married to her co-founder Zak Ismail, 36, came face to face with skin challenges in 2018 that the mother began making products in her kitchen.
I’ve made over £56k with a side hustle anyone can do – skint people must stop being scared and should try something new
Zak helped out too and whilst on maternity leave, things really took off, as the beauty guru, who lives in Wembley, London, explains: “I had really dry skin and really ugly, scaly patches that were really painful.
“I didn’t really want to use steroid creams and that’s when I started to experiment with ingredients that I knew had anti-inflammatory properties.
“I used to use black tea as a face toner, so I would brew the tea and add some oils, and I knew that it was a good anti-inflammatory.
“I formulated the body scrub in my kitchen and it had incredible results. Within a couple of days, my skin had almost completely cleared.”
We were really scared in the beginning but we took the risk. We were quite delusional
Zara Saleem
At the time, while Zara was employed as a teacher, her husband Zak was working in a corporate job.
However, their lifestyle was far from lavish, as she adds: “I wasn’t living a luxurious life at all.
“The money wasn’t great – teachers are incredibly underpaid for the amount of work that they do.”
The GlossyBox deal that changed everything
Unsure of the brand’s future, Zara shares: “It was never really meant to be a proper beauty brand – I didn’t really have it in my head how far I could take it.
“It was literally just me and my husband with the scrappy website that we made, hoping that we would get some sales.
“I had 20 bags of body scrub at the time and we had no sales coming in.
“I was like, ‘if I sell a couple of body scrubs, I’m great,’ but I was very much at home with my two children under two.”
13
Zara got candid on her highs and lows, as well as her biggest public rejection yetCredit: Delhicious
13
A collaboration with Glossybox really helped the brand to growCredit: Delhicious
13
Hair products have also proved profitable and the brand has sold over 100,000 bottles of hair oilCredit: Delhicious
But it was a huge deal with GlossyBox that really made the business take off, as Zara recognises: “Once we’d launched and started to get a couple of sales, I was adamant that I wanted to try and get some press, so I started to reach out to a couple of journalists.
“I went on the radio and then after that, we got approached by GlossyBox, who at the time were the biggest beauty box around, and beauty boxes around that time were really taking off. They wanted to place an order of 100,000 units.
“We were still making products in our kitchen. We had no manufacturer, we had no idea how we would actually be able to fulfil the order, but we took it on and turned our house into a factory.
“Our neighbours very kindly took our furniture in, we had our family and friends coming and filling body scrubs for us and we had a crazy four months where we hand-packed and made 100,000 body scrubs.
“I think it was at that point that we kind of thought, ‘this could actually be something.’”
Going viral on TikTok
After the success with GlossyBox, Zara and Zak turned to body balms – now one of their bestselling, award-winning products.
Zara explains: “We made our body balms which went super viral on TikTok because they had incredible results for people with eczema and psoriasis.
“Our fridge was full of balms and we couldn’t make enough because the minute we would put them online they were gone.
“We created waitlists. I think we had a waitlist of around 50,000 people at one point. It was actually insane.
“We started hitting five-figure sales a month. We were growing, growing, growing and sales were pouring in.”
How to start your own business
Dragon’s Den star Theo Paphitis revealed his tips for budding entrepreneurs:
One of the biggest barriers aspiring entrepreneurs and business owners face is a lack of confidence. You must believe in your idea — even more than that, be the one boring your friends to death about it.
Never be afraid to make decisions. Once you have an idea, it’s the confidence to make decisions that is crucial to starting and maintaining a business.
If you don’t take calculated risks, you’re standing still. If a decision turns out to be wrong, identify it quickly and deal with it if you can. Failing that, find someone else who can.
It’s OK not to get it right the first time. My experience of making bad decisions is what helped develop my confidence, making me who I am today.
Never underestimate the power of social media, and remember the internet has levelled the playing field for small businesses.
Don’t forget to dream. A machine can’t do that!
Whilst running the business, Zara returned to her teaching job, but shortly after, realised it was time to quit for good and focus on her business full-time. Soon after, Zak followed suit.
The couple were initially fearful to take the risk and Zara describes her actions as “delusional.” But in just three months, she had matched her monthly teacher wage.
The businesswoman shares: “We had no business background whatsoever. We were really scared in the beginning but we took the risk.
“We were quite delusional. I don’t think we thought things through enough to be honest.
“We were really lucky. We had a really supportive circle of family and friends who helped us get through.
“Who knows, if anyone did doubt us, but it wasn’t to our face.”
Rejection after rejection
But things haven’t always been easy for this couple, as Zara shares: “When we first launched, we aimed to get into Boots and buyers rejected us straight away.
“They were like, ‘no you’re not ready’, and I agree with that now.
“We’ve had multiple rejections – every single retailer you can think of rejected us.”
After sales plummeted in lockdown, just four years after launching the business, Zara decided to go on Dragons’ Den, where she asked for £50,000 for 15% of the business.
But Zara left the infamous den without an investment, as she shares: “I felt like the Dragons didn’t quite get the brand.
13
But going on Dragons’ Den was a low point for ZaraCredit: Instagram
13
Zara pitched her skincare business to the entrepreneursCredit: BBC
13
But she left without an investmentCredit: BBC Studios
“But also, what had happened was, we had a spike in our sales with the GlossyBox order, and then after that, it was lockdown, which meant that I had both of my very small children at home, so I had to step back because I didn’t have any childcare available.
“I had to make that conscious decision to not invest as much time as I could in the business and obviously to the Dragons that didn’t sound good.
“I think they just didn’t really get it and they thought we were a TikTok brand. It felt like a little bit more of an excuse as to why they may not have wanted to invest.”
Reflecting on her time on the BBC show, the mother admits: “Dragons’ Den was probably the biggest and the most public rejection I’ve had, which was really difficult.
“Even before it aired, I was really nervous because I felt like I’d let myself down, I felt like I’d let the brand down because I didn’t get the investment.
“It was a really tough experience and at the time, I felt like I doubted everything about the brand.
I thought it would be good if I could have secured the investment, not for the money but more for the guidance, because obviously I didn’t have a mentor and we didn’t really know what we were doing
Zara Saleem
“They didn’t think it would scale and they didn’t think it was investable because of that one dip.
“And actually, rejection is always redirection and it’s something you need to overcome if you truly believe in whatever it is that you’re building.
“And I do fully believe in the brand, I believe in the ethos and the values of it, so I guess that keeps me going.
“I wasn’t relying on Dragons’ Den for the success of the business. I thought it would be good if I could have secured the investment, not for the money but more for the guidance, because obviously I didn’t have a mentor and we didn’t really know what we were doing.”
Expansion and £120,000 salaries
But despite walking away empty handed, it didn’t take long for things to pick up again for Delhicious.
As well as being online for Debenhams, Zara says: “Retail was a big move for us – we always wanted to be on the high street. We are in store in Beauty Base and exclusively in store with Superdrug.”
Things have since expanded from Zara and Zak’s kitchen and now, Delhicious is a team of five.
Zara adds: “We’ve got all UK manufacturers now – that process took us quite a long time.
Zara’s advice for those starting out in business
FOR those looking to start their own company, Zara shares her top tips.
She advises: “Even if it’s not perfect, just start. The way our brand looks now is very different to what it looked like five years ago. You can always change as you grow.
“I think a lot of women are held back by the idea that it needs to be perfect. Your business idea does not need to be perfect, you just need to make a start and believe that you can do it.
“You don’t need experience or lots of money. You do need to have resilience and determination, because you will get rejected a lot.
“It’s hard, business is hard, but don’t let the rejections put you off and just keep going. And be prepared for a lot of rejections.”
“Obviously when you’re making products at home, it’s a very different process – you’re making a couple of hundred to now making thousands at a time.”
“We used to pack every single order that used to come in. Now we have a fulfilment centre and it’s a very, streamlined process compared to how it was before, which was very hands-on by me and Zak literally seeing every order coming in, making the products, printing labels, and packing them ourselves.
“We’ve outsourced all of that so we can actually focus on the growth of the business.”
Being able to focus on the business growth has proved profitable for Zara and now, both she and Zak are on £120,000 salaries.
Life-changing success
Reflecting on the company’s success, she acknowledges: “We’ve had six-figure months – we’ve done at least £200,000 in one month.
“It’s been so life-changing in so many ways. Financially, to have that ease of mind, it’s incredible.
“I’m not a big spender but if we want to go on a nice holiday, we can go on a nice holiday.
“We’ve recently done a big house renovation, which was amazing – it’s something we’ve always wanted to do.
13
Zara now gets a salary of £120,000Credit: Delhicious
13
She is no longer making products and instead, focuses on growing the brandCredit: Delhicious
13
She wants more women to get into businessCredit: Delhicious
“Going from a £27,000 salary to then being able to be on six-figures now – I would never have been able to get that in teaching.
“We’re very, very blessed and very lucky, but we’ve worked really hard for it.
“I’m still very modest, I’m very conscious of the way that I spend my money, and that’s something that I pass on to my children as well.”
Now that Zara is her own boss, she has much more flexibility over her life, as she beams: “I absolutely love that I can do all the school drop-offs and pick-ups. I have a lot of flexibility over my time which is so nice.
“Of course, we still do work a lot. People get the impression that when you run your own business, you’re not working as much.
“We work a lot but it’s on our own terms – that was the one thing that I couldn’t get in teaching and it used to break my heart.”
Zara is now on a mission to get more women into the industry, as she continues: “I’m a really big advocate for women going into business. I think it’s such a great way for women to be independent, but still be able to be present in their other roles. We need more women in business.”
Discussing the future of the business, Zara concludes: “Hopefully we’re going outside of the UK now as well and hoping to be able to expand distribution and go to more multiple retailers as well.
Alix Lapri, who portrayed Effie Morales on the Starz show “Power,” was arrested last week in Atlanta on suspicion of cruelty to children in the third degree and disorderly conduct, according to county records.
The actor, whose full name is Alexus Lapri Geier, was released the following day. Details on the circumstances surrounding the Aug. 17 arrest were not immediately clear.
The 28-year-old actor appeared in several episodes of “Power” as well as its sequel, “Power Book II: Ghost.” She also had a role in the film “Den of Thieves.” But Lapri hit the limelight as a singer.
She released an EP in 2012 titled “I Am Alix Lapri.” Lapri also appeared on BET’s sitcom “Reed Between the Lines” alongside Tracee Ellis Ross and Malcolm-Jamal Warner.
The state of Georgia considers cruelty to children in the third degree to be a misdemeanor.
It occurs when a person “intentionally allows a child under age 18 to witness the commission of a forcible felony, battery, or family violence battery,” according to Child Welfare.
Lapri’s manager did not respond Tuesday to a request for comment by The Times. Calls to the DeKalb County Sheriff’s Office were not immediately returned.
Dragons’ Den star Alessandro Savelli left the popular show empty-handed but ended up being worth £40million with his pasta company
22:53, 24 Aug 2025Updated 22:53, 24 Aug 2025
Dragons’ Den star called ‘delusional disaster’ now worth £40million(Image: BBC)
Dragons’ Den star Alessandro Savelli left the show empty-handed but ended up being worth £40million. The star co-founded and is the CEO of the popular Pasta Evangelists – a fresh pasta brand which originally started as letter box posted food kits.
Following his appearance on the show, Alessandro’s company is set to open 100 new restaurants across the UK in the next few years, including in the Midlands, Scotland and in the south of England. In a recent chat with The Grocer, the CEO discussed the brand’s plans to expand.
He said they’re pumping £30million into new restaurants. “The demand for our fresh, beautifully cooked artisan pasta is growing,” he explained.
The star co-founded and is the CEO of the popular Pasta Evangelists (Image: BBC)
“Our intention is to become the UK’s fastest-growing, casual dining hot spot and the hottest place to eat for pasta lovers of all ages.”
He continued: “The hospitality industry is going through tough times at the moment, but we are confident that our business model is robust and dynamic.
“And the proof of this is we have already bucked the trend with the confirmed opening of five more restaurants in the space of three months, and more to come.”
Alessandro and his business partner Finn Lagun took part in the show in 2018 asking for a £75,000 investment for a 2.5 per cent cut of the company. Their pitch was rejected, with Jenny Campbell saying Finn was ‘delusional’ and ‘a disaster’.
Anshu Ahuja also failed to get the Dragons to invest(Image: BBC)
There were many people who were rejected on Dragons’ Den, including Anshu Ahuja – who entered the Den in an episode that aired, hoping to seek £100,000 for 3 percent of her business, DabbaDrop.
The founder and her business partner had built up their sustainable takeaway business, inspired by the dabbawala system of Mumbai, in 2018, and had valued the business at more than £3,000,000 just a few years later.
The entrepreneur was looking for investment from the likes of Peter Jones, Sara Davies, Touker Suleyman, Deborah Meaden, and Steven Bartlett to help upscale DabbaDrop and encourage its growth outside of London.
However, despite her inspirational ethics behind the sustainable product, and the fact that DabbaDrop had turned over more than £800,000 in its latest year, Anshu failed to convince the Dragons to invest.
Speaking about the show, she said: “We had done quite a lot of work going into Dragons’ Den and our own fundraising round, so the £4million valuation was independently valued, based on our £850,000 revenue and a lifetime value of the 1,500 subscribers at that point of nearly £400 per subscriber. At that point, we also had a 1,000-person waiting list, which is currently, even before airing, standing at 4,000 people.”
Anshu knew it was a “risk” to go on national TV and pitch her business, but was willing to take the leap as the team was fundraising for DabbaDrop at the time of being approached for the show.
They’d already received interest from more than 2,000 investors, had reached millions of views on an Instagram reel, and pledged more than £1,000,000.
AN ENTREPRENEUR whose restaurant idea was rejected as “a disaster” on Dragons’ Den is set to open 100 new outlets of his popular chain.
Alessandro Savelli, who co-founded Pasta Evangelists and currently serves as its CEO, says the chain is aiming to become the UK’s “fastest-growing, casual dining hot spot”.
5
Pasta Evangelists was panned by business experts on Dragons’ Den in 2018Credit: BBC
5
Now, the company is worth millions of pounds and is aiming to open 100 new restaurants across the UKCredit: Pasta Evangelists – Supplied
5
The co-founders had asked for a £75,000 investment for a 2.5 per cent stake in the company during their appearance on the BBC showCredit: BBC
Now worth around £40 million, Pasta Evangelists was rejected on Dragons’ Den by business experts in 2018 when Savelli and co-founder Finn Lagun asked for a £75,000 investment for a 2.5 per cent cut of the company.
Dragon Jenny Campbell even called Finn “delusional” and “a disaster” during their pitch.
However, the entrepreneurs have no doubt had the last laugh as their business is now set for major expansion.
Pasta Evangelists says it will invest £30 million into new restaurants, creating up to 1,500 jobs.
It hopes to open 100 new restaurants across the UK in the next five years, including in the south of England, the Midlands, and Scotland.
The company is also aiming to develop a “Pasta Apprenticeship” scheme to attract new staff and help the current workforce develop new skills and knowledge, reports The Grocer.
Savelli said: “The demand for our fresh, beautifully cooked artisan pasta is growing.
“Our intention is to become the UK’s fastest-growing, casual dining hot spot and the hottest place to eat for pasta lovers of all ages.
“Sustainable growth has always been our plan.
“The hospitality industry is going through tough times at the moment, but we are confident that our business model is robust and dynamic, and the proof of this is we have already bucked the trend with the confirmed opening of five more restaurants in the space of three months, and more to come.”
Pasta Evangelists enter Dragons Den
The chain opened a restaurant in Farringdon, central London, this summer as well as its first outside of the capital in Guildford in July.
Three new London locations are set to open in the coming weeks, helping carry the total number of outlets to 11 as we head into autumn.
Chancellor Rachel Reeves said the plans were “great news” and highlighted the “dynamism and resilience of British businesses”.
The restaurant has had a remarkable success story since its Dragons’ Den miss.
Recalling their appearance on the BBC show, Finn said he was “shaking life a leaf” before walking out to pitch his business.
He added that he was left devastated by the business experts’ “vicious” comments.
Speaking to The Sun in 2023, he said: “I never would have expected to be called a ‘disaster’ or ‘delusional‘ on national TV – they were vicious things to say to a young entrepreneur.
“To use that kind of language against a young, passionate person was dismaying. I would never talk to any young entrepreneur like that.”
Despite their lack of faith in the business, the Dragons are no doubt feeling red in the face now as Pasta Evangelists is one of the UK’s biggest fresh pasta companies.
It has also earned the highest praise from many voices, including chef Gordon Ramsay.
SCARRED BY EXPERIENCE ON DRAGONS’ DEN
While Pasta Evangelists has gone on to huge success, Finn says he’s still scarred by his experience in the Den.
“We received an extremely strong, negative, visceral reaction,” he says.
“I was 24 years old when I went on Dragons’ Den, so for a seasoned entrepreneur like Jenny Campbell to call me ‘delusional’ and a ‘disaster’ was so vicious… Jenny was savage.
“At one point she said, ‘I like it’ and I replied, ‘Thank you’, only for her to say, ‘I like it because it’s a brilliant business lesson in how not to set up and run a business’.
“I was mortified, I felt like an idiot having grinned at her and thanked her. She was deliberately trying to take me for a ride for entertainment.”
Finn adds: “I don’t want to sound like the Virgin Mary but if the tables were turned and I was Jenny Campbell, I would have apologised.
“If I saw the business had turned into the UK’s biggest pasta company in a few years I’d say, ‘Well done, you defied expectations’ and maybe even offer a little contrition or an apology.”
5
Finn Lagun said he was left scarred by his experience on the showCredit: BBC
5
Pasta Evangelists will operate 11 stores across southern England by the end of summerCredit: Pasta Evangelists
A DRAGON’S Den winner and former Team GB gold medallist fraudulently used Covid loans to buy himself a £1.8million mansion.
Rick Beardsell illegally pocketed £100,000 worth of taxpayers cash to purchase his home – despite receiving a £75,000 investment during his stint on the BBC show.
6
Beardsell received £75,000 in investments after appearing on Dragon’s DenCredit: Cavendish
6
The British world sprinting champion illegally pocketed two Covid Bounce Back business loans to buy himself a £1.8m mansionCredit: Cavendish
6
Beardsell was only entitled to apply for one loan worth £50,000, but fraudulently applied for twoCredit: Cavendish
The 46-year-old fiddled two Covid Bounce Back loans to buy himself five-bed Holly House in the exclusive village of Prestbury, Cheshire.
Dad-of-two Beardsell was only entitled to apply for one loan worth £50,000, but fraudulently applied for two and greatly exaggerated his annual turnover by up to 23 times.
It came after the world champion sprinter had successfully secured investments from TV Dragons Tej Lalvani andDeborah Meadenfor his successful protein shake bottle business, ShakeSphere.
Chester Crown Court heard he applied for the loan to prop up his other company, Sports Creative Ltd, but none of the money went towards the sportswear business.
Prosecutor Geoff Whealan told the court Beardsell made the fraudulent applications to HSBC in December 2020 and then to NatWest in January 2021.
He said: ”The defendant stated on the HSBC form that the turnover of Sports Creative was £485,000 and on the NatWest form said it was £320,000.
“But unaudited financial statements showed turnover for the year end February 2020 was £20,622.
”The turnover was clearly exaggerated to secure the maximum bounce back loan.
“Subsequent transactions showed the bounce back loan funds were not being used for the economic benefit or business purposes of Sports Creative at this time.”
The money arrived in Sports Creative’s account in January 2021, but then almost £400,000 was transferred to Beardsell’s personal Santander account in the space of six months.
Then £431,160.80, including the remaining bounce back loan funds, was transferred to a firm of solicitors for the purchase of Holly House he bought with his wife Ezster.
Mr Whelan added: ”In effect the bounce back loan funds had been used for this purchase.
Shocking moment Dragons’ Den winner Ross Mendham smashes £100k Ferrari after ploughing into bike racks in city centre
“It can be inferred from the defendant’s conduct that it was his intention to use the bounce back loans for this purpose at the time he made the application for it.”
Beardsell, who won two World Records for sprinting, faced three years in jail after he admitted two charges of fraud.
In October 2024, he attended an interview under caution at the Insolvency Services offices.
In a statement he said: ”The guidance pertaining to Bounce Back Loans indicated that the proceeds of such loans may be utilised for any purpose that yields a direct benefit to the company.
”At that juncture, I sought professional advice and was advised that such purposes include, but are not limited to, the coverage of overhead expenses or outstanding liabilities, as well as the investment in company assets or property.
“The funds that were transferred to my personal account constituted a director’s loan and other economical overheads for the business.”
Mitigating, his counsel Nichola Cafferkey explained that the loans had been repaid in full to the banks.
She said: ”The loss of his good character is of some significance in respect of a man who has dedicated his life to his family, his professional entities and also his sporting endeavours.
“These offences were out of character and were committed four years ago.
“He has taken responsibility and repaid the money back. He knows that it’s his own fault.
“He has brought shame on his family and brought shame on himself.
”His wife is also his business partner and concerns that they have had about the ability to provide financially for their young children have been significant.”
The court also heard that Beardsell had suffered a series of medical issues both before and after securing the loans.
Ms Cafferkey continued: “A year prior to the submission of the first loan application, the defendant was diagnosed with an aggressive form of testicular cancer and required surgery and extensive chemotherapy.
“The chemotherapy was successful but led to some significant side effects.
”One of those being vertigo, of which he had a severe episode which required hospitalisation and thereafter there are ongoing long-term issues as a result of that.
6
Beardsell was sentenced to 18 months in prison, suspended for two yearsCredit: Cavendish
6
Hundreds of thousands of pounds were transferred to a firm of solicitors for the purchase of Holly HouseCredit: Cavendish
“The investigations brought on by the defendant’s own actions has had an impact on his family which has led to a situation where he has been experiencing significant stress over the past few years.
“On top of that there are ongoing knee pains associated with his athletic success at national and international level.
“He has been running a business for many years without issue and it is plain he is extremely remorseful and regretful for his actions.
“The impact on his wife’s physical health in terms of stress and strain has been significant. There has been significant weight loss and insomnia.
“This will be the only time that Richard Beardsell appears before the court.”
Beardsell was sentenced to 18 months in prison, suspended for two years.
He was also ordered to complete 250 hours of unpaid work and pay costs of £11,142.70.
Judge Simon Berkson told Beardsell: “You fraudulently lied and lied again in your applications for these loans.
“They were supposed to be for use in keeping your business running but the money was used for your own personal needs and the needs of your family.
“This is not a victimless crime. The government was trying to help struggling businesses at the time of national crisis.
“People were in lock down, people were dying and people were very ill at the time when people required their public services.
“You used fraudulently obtained public funds for your own use, depriving honest people of the scheme’s funds when the country was in crisis.
“You are a generally successful man both in business and in sports, particularly your involvement with athletics.
“You continue to run your business and it was on the TV programme Dragons’ Den.
“You are a married person with two children and they are young children. You have survived an aggressive form of cancer.
“I have concluded that an immediate custodial sentence would have a significant harmful impact on your wife and children.”
6
He was ordered to complete 250 hours of unpaid work and pay costs of £11,142.70Credit: Cavendish
Orange County Dist. Atty. Todd Spitzer appeared at a civil trial this week and denied claims he retaliated against a former executive and whistleblower who sought to protect female prosecutors who were sexually harassed in the D.A.’s office.
In a lawsuit filed against the county by former senior assistant Dist. Atty. Tracy Miller, at one point the highest-ranking woman in the prosecutors office, Spitzer and others are accused of retaliation and trying to force Miller out of her job after she questioned Spitzer’s actions as D.A. Those actions included his handling of allegations that a male superior, who was also the best man at Spitzer’s wedding, sexually harassed young female prosecutors.
Spitzer denied the accusations during hours of testimony that became at times tense and emotional. In a San Diego courtroom this week, Spitzer acknowledged deep tensions within the D.A.’s office following his 2018 election victory over former Orange County Dist. Atty. Tony Rackauckas.
Spitzer, who appeared to wipe away tears during his testimony, told jurors he believed he was walking “in the lions’ den” after winning the election and expected opposition from employees who had worked for Rackauckas.
“I knew it was going to be miserable, and it was miserable,” Spitzer said, his voice cracking.
In her lawsuit, Miller alleges that Spitzer and former chief assistant Dist. Atty. Shawn Nelson — who is now an Orange County Superior Court Judge — forced the prosecutor out through “purposeful and intentional retaliation.” The reason for this, Miller alleges, is that she was protecting female subordinates who had reported sexual misconduct by a male superior, Gary LoGalbo, who is now deceased.
“Miller was punished for refusing to allow Spitzer to lionize the predator, gaslight, and further savage the reputation of the victims,” her lawsuit says.
According to the suit, Miller had also raised concerns about Spitzer’s handling of the D.A.’s office, including worries that Spitzer had violated the Racial Justice Act by bringing up questions of race while trying to determine whether or not to seek the death penalty against a Black defendant. She also claimed that Spitzer considered a prosecutor’s race in assignments and that he had possibly undermined a homicide case.
But it was the allegations of sexual harassment against LoGalbo, a former friend and roommate of Spitzer’s, that plaintiff attorneys say most threatened Spitzer’s leadership and prompted him to target Miller.
“[Spitzer] knew that if this was believed, the (district attorney’s) office would suffer one of the worst scandals ever,” said John Barnett, an attorney representing Miller during his opening statement Monday. “He punished (Miller) for protecting one of her young prosecutors.”
Attorneys representing the county, as well as Spitzer and Nelson, argue that the men wanted Miller to stay in the prosecutor’s office and valued her experience, pointing out they promoted four women to top positions due to her recommendations.
Defense Attorney Tracey Kennedy argued during her opening statement Monday that even though LoGalbo had been friends with Spitzer years ago, the relationship had changed by the time the allegations were raised.
“(Spitzer) had no reason to protect Mr. LoGalbo at the expense of the Orange County DA’s office, and the expense of his career,” Kennedy said.
Instead, she said, Spitzer and Nelson had set out to make much needed reforms for the office.
“They had a mission to change the D.A.’s office,” she said.
The county investigation substantiated the sexual harassment allegations against LoGalbo, but an April 2021 report found that allegations of retaliation were unsubstantiated because no actions were taken against the employees.
Much of Spitzer’s time on the witness stand Tuesday centered on his role in the LoGalbo investigation, and what appeared to be differing versions of what occurred. At one point during questioning, Spitzer disclosed that the version of events he gave the county’s investigator during the internal probe — about a highly scrutinized private meeting with a supervisor — had been “inaccurate.”
Chris Duff, a former senior deputy district attorney, had told the county investigator that Spitzer met with him in the law library of a Westminster courthouse in January 2021 and instructed him to write up one of the sexual harassment victims in her upcoming evaluation for being “untruthful.” Duff said he refused to do so, according to a report of the internal investigation.
Spitzer initially denied discussing the evaluation during the meeting and told the investigator, Elisabeth Frater, that he “never said that” to Duff because he didn’t want anything “to be perceived in any way whatsoever that we were retaliating against her.”
But in court this week, Spitzer offered a different version of events.
“What I told Frater was inaccurate,” Spitzer said, adding that he did discuss concerns he had about the female prosecutor’s honesty regarding an email she wrote. “I did talk to Duff about that.”
But Spitzer maintained his concerns were about the prosecutor’s veracity, and not about the claims she had raised against LoGalbo.
After Duff met with Spitzer, Miller sent a note to Spitzer telling the district attorney she was aware of the conversation, and arguing against writing up the female prosecutor.
During his testimony, Spitzer said that he was disappointed with Miller, and that she had not gone directly to him with her concerns about various issues.
At one point, Spitzer said, he had grown to wonder why Miller would take notes during executive meetings.
“You could see anytime a subject came up, Tracy was taking notes about our meetings,” Spitzer said. “There was a point of time where it was very curious to me, why do you seem to be memorializing everything we’re doing?”
When he was first elected in 2018, Spitzer said he believed he was walking “in the lions’ den” and expected opposition from his direct reports. For that reason, he said, he chose Shawn Nelson to be his number two.
“I picked him because I was going into battle, in the lions’ den,” Spitzer said.
Miller’s lawsuit is just the latest in a series of troubles that have recently hit the district attorney’s office, including allegations of retaliation raised by top prosecutors and investigators in the office.
The county is also facing eight sexual harassment lawsuits involving allegations against LoGalbo.
In March, a now-retired investigator of the office also sent letters to the California attorney general, the U.S. Department of Justice, the State Bar of California, and other agencies to investigate Spitzer and other top officials at the prosecutor’s office.