Amorim has earned a reputation for his explosive news conferences since joining United in November 2024.
In January 2025, he described his team as “maybe the worst” in the 147-year history of the club.
“One of his best traits and most likeable things about him has always been his ability to be quite punchy in his press conferences,” former United centre-back Rio Ferdinand said on his podcast.
“He was upbeat, and he had quite a jovial way about him.”
The Portuguese manager’s comments last month on striker Chido Obi and left-back Harry Amass, both 18, also raised questions over his commitment to the club’s academy.
Trying to emphasise he is not scared to play young players, he criticised the performance levels of Obi and Amass, who is on loan at Sheffield Wednesday.
“Amass was doing really well and got player of the month, while you had Chido scoring goals in the under-21s,” said former United defender Phil Jones on BBC Radio 5 Live’s The Monday Night Club.
“The academy is a massive part and will always be a massive part of the DNA of the club and I don’t think that helped him in any way.”
Carragher, who believes Amorim would be “bottom of the list” of managers to have succeeded Sir Alex Ferguson at the club since 2013, added: “Best part of Amorim was his performances in the press conferences – not the performances of his teams.
“At times, it felt like he was as good a pundit as Gary Neville when talking about United. But the problem was that he was the manager.”
“I don’t think it’s been just sound bites from Amorim,” Neville said.
“I think he’s meant every single word that he said. I think that he’s a real, genuine, honest guy. I don’t think he’s someone who’s playing the game. He was absolutely all in every time he did anything.
“But if the performances are that poor and the results are so poor, it doesn’t matter how likeable or honest you are. You’re going to get sacked at a club like United.”