Sun. Nov 24th, 2024
Occasional Digest - a story for you

Ozanne believes the discussion surrounding ‘conversion therapy’ has frequently become a “proxy debate for many other debates” which, she says, has been “hijacked by the gender critical movement” who have moved the focus away from the actual issue at hand and instead focused it on their perceived threat of gender identity. “What’s frustrated me is that it’s really muddied and confused people as to what conversion practices actually are and, if we can get back to a clear definition, that conversion practices are any practice where the perpetrator has a predetermined purpose of trying to make you into something you’re not, then that covers all cases of anybody trying to do anything to someone in their care where they have a mindset that says you cannot be gay or you cannot be transgender,” she adds. “If we could stick to that clarity, we’d have got this, I think, banned years ago.”

This was prominent during the second reading of Labour MP Lloyd Russell-Moyle’s Conversion Practices (Prohibition) Bill on 1 March, which eventually became plagued by anti-trans rhetoric unrelated to the real issue at hand. Alicia Kearns, Conservative MP and Chair of the Foreign Affairs Committee, directly addressed those calling for the ‘LGB’ to be separated from the ‘T’, an argument that has been at the core of the debate surrounding ‘conversion therapy’ in recent years: “By removing the ‘T’, you are suggesting that trans people do not exist. You are suggesting they are lesser than other LGB people and I will not stand for that because it was trans people who stood with gay people at Stonewall, it was trans people who stood alongside for LGB rights. So when you remove the ‘T’, you suggest that they are lesser and, I will happily discuss with you the intricacies of legislation, but when you choose to eradicate, then that is wrong.”

The legislation, which was brought forward in the form of a Private Members’ Bill and faced opposition from the government in the Commons, ultimately failed to advance to the committee stage – bringing to an end another attempt to outlaw ‘conversion therapy’. Now, survivors of the practice will likely have to wait until after the next general election for such a law to be introduced, which Labour has vowed to do

“I am very angry by the total lack of moral backbone shown by the government today who, having been given multiple opportunities by Lloyd Russell-Moyle to make amendments, chose not to do so and opposed the bill,” Ozanne told GAY TIMES after the debate on 1 March. “Lloyd had done what they had not – he presented a bill that had broad consensus across the house. We now know that despite their multiple promises, they have no intention of protecting LGBT people from these abusive practices.”

Source link