She said the dupes gave the same results and were so cheap that they should be “illegal.”
Jacquelyn (@jacquelynmengel) shared the makeup dupe in a viral TikTok video.
She thought the drugstore products are an “exact” dupe for the cult-favorite brand’s Pillowtalk lipstick and lip liner.
“This is seriously the best Pillow Talk dupe I’ve ever found,” she said.
“It’s so affordable, it should be illegal.”
She held up the $5 NYX Lip Liner in the shade Peekaboo Neutral, which she thought was spot-on for the Pillow Talk version.
The “star of the show,” however, was the $7 L’Oreal Paris Riche lipstick in shade 173.
After applying the lip combo, she explained that the only discernible difference between the drugstore dupes and the luxury brand’s $25 lip liner and $35 lipstick was the finish.
While she found the Pillow Talk products to be more matte, she revealed she preferred the dupes’ satin finish.
Most read in Hair & Beauty
The result, she added, had the added benefit of looking glossy on top of being a great color match.
Makeup fans thanked her for putting them on to the drugstore dupe.
“Yes, girl thanks! Finally the best Pillow Talk dupe,” said one commenter.
“I have these, literally a dupe,” agreed another.
“Lol running to Target right now because of you,” said a third.
“Bought these so fast it’s actually embarrassing,” joked one commenter.
Many loyal customers of the dupes raved about its performance and quality.
“I’ve been using this lip liner every day for like three years,” said one long-time fan.
“I haven’t been able to find Peekaboo Neutral in any stores for so long and it’s my fav lip liner,” said another.
“I’ve bought 5 tubes of that lipstick. It’s amazing,” said a third.
2