The Florida High School Athletic Assn. axed the questions Thursday after listening to a flood of complaints contained in letters read aloud during an emergency meeting of the board.
Answering the questions was optional, but an association advisory committee recently recommended that it be mandatory, sparking the firestorm of criticism.
Some called the questions “humiliating” and “invasive,” and others suggested they were connected to a recent bill barring transgender girls and women from playing on public school teams intended for student athletes identified as girls at birth.
“This is another way to shame girls,” Connie DeWitt said in a letter.
Dr. Deborah White wrote that there was “zero” reason for a school to know about students’ menstrual history.
“The only reason is to weed out transgender kids who may not have periods,” White’s letter said. “As a doctor I would never fill out this form.”
Republican Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis signed the bill in 2021, thrusting the state into the national cultural debate over transgender rights. DeSantis is widely believed to be considering a run for president next year on a deeply conservative platform.
The association’s spokesperson has said the proposed changes were not in response to concerns about transgender athletes competing in women’s sports, as some social media users have contended. Association president John Gerdes said politics played no part in the discussions, though the newly adopted form does ask for “sex assigned at birth.”
“This governor and his office had nothing to do with this,” Gerdes said Thursday.
The four-page form adopted by the board will still contain questions about mental health, alcohol and drug use and family health history, but the answers will stay in the offices of the healthcare practitioners who conduct the students’ medical screenings. Schools will get only the page declaring a student’s medical eligibility.
The association’s medical advisory committee, which recommended to the board that it make menstrual histories on the form mandatory, has said it was following national guidelines for sports physicals developed by the American Academy of Family Physicians, the American Academy of Pediatrics, the American College of Sports Medicine and other groups.
The guidelines state that menstrual history is an “essential discussion for female athletes” because period abnormalities could be a sign of “low energy availability, pregnancy, or other gynecologic or medical conditions.”
However, the chair-elect of the American Academy of Pediatrics’ Council on Sports Medicine & Fitness told the Associated Press on Thursday that the earlier Florida proposal wasn’t consistent with its guidelines since the academy recommends only that a medical eligibility form be sent to the school, not personal medical information.
“And we recognize that is very problematic,” said Rebecca Carl, an associate professor of pediatrics at Northwestern University. “These were not designed to be shared with the schools.”
Two of the board members who voted against eliminating the questions altogether said there was no reason menstrual information couldn’t still be included on the forms and stored at medical practitioners’ offices.
Sports eligibility evaluations are the only opportunity some students have to meet with healthcare providers, and having the questions on the form can help detect any medical problems, said board member Chris Patricca.
“Student athletes are safer and better protected by the inclusion of these questions,” she said.