Airline staff laid-off during the pandemic have taken up better-paying jobs with less responsibility in other industries and are now reluctant to come back, industry experts have warned MPs.
The industry is currently in the grips of a staffing crisis – sparking chaotic scenes of long queues and abandoned luggage at airports and resulting in hundreds of flights being cancelled.
Yesterday, as the chaos continued at airports, including long queues at Manchester, MPs were warned how travel firms were struggling to bring back staff following mass redundancies last year.
One employment expert, Danny Brooks, founder and CEO of Virtual Human Resources, said airline firms had been forced to axe thousands of workers in the gap between the end of the Government’s furlough scheme and the end of all Covid travel restrictions.
Comparing the situation to ‘like an alien spaceship removing staff from the supply chain’, he said many of them had now settled in new jobs including as heat-engineers or in Amazon warehouses.
His comments came as figures from the Office of National Statistics (ONS) today revealed how travel firms were now facing stiff competition in the labour markets, with job vacancies reach a record high.
According to the figures, companies across Britain sought 1.3million new members of staff in the three months to May, a record high number of vacancies to fill.
Meanwhile figures show how employment levels have fallen in the air transport industry. ONS data shows there were some 81,000 people employed in March 2020, compared to just 70,000 in March this year – a fall of 14 per cent.
It comes as airlines were told last night to ensure the recent ‘unacceptable scenes’ at British airports do not drag on into summer.
The regulator, the Civil Aviation Authority (CAA), and the Government urged carriers to ensure planned flights are ‘deliverable’.
The warning came as consumer group Which? said firms were ‘blatantly flouting’ passenger rights through practices such as taking bookings for flights which may not be able to run.
Tens of thousands of passengers have been affected by flight cancellations and long queues at airports in recent months, particularly during Easter and last month’s half-term school holiday.
And today holidaymakers said they were facing ‘chaos’ once again at Manchester airport, with ‘three hour’ queues and hundreds of passengers being funnelled through ‘just two’ security desks.
Pictures and video show a huge line of people snaking around the airport terminal as the wait to go through airport security at the under-pressure airport.
Holidaymakers say they are facing ‘chaos’ once again at Manchester airport, with ‘three hour’ queues and hundreds of passengers being funnelled through ‘just one’ security desk. Some passengers say they arrived three hours early for their flights, only to have to be pulled from the queues and fast-tracked through to the gate to avoid missing their flights
Pictures and video show a huge line of people snaking around the airport terminal as the wait to go through airport security at the under-pressure airport
Others say hundreds of passengers were being funnelled through just two security desks. Another passenger described the situation as a ‘fiasco’. It comes after weeks of disruption at the airport, and others such as Birmingham and Bristol, and also on occasion Heathrow and Gatwick
According to the figures, companies across Britain sought 1.3million new members of staff in the three months to May, a record high number of vacancies to fill
Yesterday MPs were briefed on the situation with airline staff at a meeting of the Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (BEIS) Committee.
Danny Brooks, founder and CEO of Virtual Human Resources, told the BEIS committee that the chaos was mainly due to the a skills gap in the aviation jobs market.
He said: ”A lot of the workers were furloughed, furlough came to end in September last year. A lot of the aviation restrictions were lifted earlier this year. So there is a big disconnect in the period.
‘A lot of the airlines and operators of the aviation supply chain had to protect themselves to survive to fight another day, which resulted in a lot of redundancies. BA laid of 10,000 people, easyJet 5,000, Swissport I believe a third of their workforce.
‘These people have left the industry for good. For a number of reasons, necessity, they’ve gone to competitor industries, maybe some of the things like Amazon warehouses at the lower-skilled end. At the skilled end people have become heating engineers.
‘It is almost like an alien spaceship has come along and taken several million people out the supply chain, but that is not the case – they’ve just gone into different areas and are reticent to come back, because of boom bust cycles, because of regards to furlough and work life balance, aviation working is anti-social hours and they can earn comparative rates of pay with less responsibility.
Meanwhile, Oliver Richardson, national officer for civil aviation at trade union Unite, told the committee that a ranking of airlines based on their number of cancellations ‘almost exactly corresponds’ with how many jobs they cut during the pandemic.
He said Ryanair, which made no compulsory redundancies, is in a ‘different position from the likes of British Airways’, which has been forced to cancel more than 100 daily flights in recent weeks due to staff shortages after implementing severe job losses in 2020.
‘They did get rid of too many people in a number of instances,’ Mr Richardson said.
But British Airways corporate affairs director Lisa Tremble refused to acknowledge that the job cuts are contributing to cancellations.
Labour MP Darren Jones, who chairs the committee, repeatedly pressed her on the issue.
He asked: ‘Do you think there was a connection between sacking 10,000 members of your staff using aggressive fire-and-rehire tactics, and now cancelling the most flights per day?’
Ms Tremble said ‘it’s very complicated’, stating that the company ‘had to protect as many jobs as possible’.
Mr Jones responded: ‘We’ve asked you a very direct question, I think three times, and you’ve chosen not to answer it.’
EasyJet chief operating officer Sophie Deckers insisted that the Luton-based airline – which is also making a large number of cancellations – did plan for the spike in demand for travel but delays in new cabin crew recruits receiving security passes ‘caught us by surprise’.
She said the process is typically taking around 14 weeks, compared with 10 weeks before the pandemic.
The delay is due to difficulties many individuals are having obtaining reference for all the jobs they have done in the past five years, with the pandemic often creating complicated employment histories.
‘In many cases, people have had 10 jobs in the last couple of years,’ Ms Deckers said.
‘Maybe some of them were only for a couple of weeks, but we’re required to get a reference from each of those, so that’s what’s taking the length of time.
‘We have today 142 crew ready and trained to go online that don’t have their ID passes.’
Meanwhile, airlines were told last night to ensure the recent ‘unacceptable scenes’ at British airports do not drag on into summer.
The regulator, the Civil Aviation Authority (CAA), and the Government urged carriers to ensure planned flights are ‘deliverable’.
The warning came as consumer group Which? said firms were ‘blatantly flouting’ passenger rights through practices such as taking bookings for flights which may not be able to run.
Tens of thousands of passengers have been affected by flight cancellations and long queues at airports in recent months, particularly during Easter and last month’s half-term school holiday.
Passengers at Bristol Airport endured delayed and cancelled flights plus long queues before 4am on Monday
Manchester Airport’s Terminal One was also crowded and understaffed early on Monday this week, with lines stretching far
A passenger tweeted this picture of cases piled on top of one another at Glasgow Airport, describing an ‘absolute shambles’
A passenger said this was the scene at Edinburgh, 5.25am on Tuesday, adding: ‘What a joke’
Bristol Airport (pictured, one passenger sleeps off a delay) was ranked in a recent study as among the very worst in the UK
Holidaymakers queue for check-in at the Jet2 area of Manchester Airport’s Terminal Two, Monday in the early hours
One passenger passing through Edinburgh Airport yesterday morning described ‘huge chaos’ at passport control
The disruption has been blamed on aviation firms struggling to recruit enough staff to cope with demand for travel after thousands of jobs were cut during the pandemic.
A joint letter from the CAA and Department for Transport said schedules should be ‘resilient for unplanned and inevitable operational challenges’. Air industry representatives told the Commons business, energy and industrial strategy committee that staff shortages may not be fixed by the summer.
Meanwhile new Home Office data made clear the scale of the passport backlog earlier this year, revealing that more than 35,000 people waited longer than ten weeks for their document in the first three months of 2022.
Also today, Heathrow Airport’s Terminal Four reopened for the first time in two years ahead of the peak summer season, with the first airline flying out being Qatar Airways to Doha – and 30 others are set to join soon.
As passengers again reported huge queues yesterday morning at Manchester, Edinburgh and Belfast airports – and others tweeted pictures of chaos overnight at Gatwick and Bristol, easyJet made further flight cancellations.
It axed 16 flights at Gatwick today – eight departures to Almeria, Catania, Belfast, Preveza, Krakow, Madrid, Prague and Montpellier; and eight arrivals from Belfast, Montpellier, Milan, Catania, Preveza, Prague, Madrid and Krakow.
Sue Davies, head of consumer rights at consumer group Which?, said the cancellation of thousands of flights and long queues at airports in recent months were caused by the impact of staffing shortages being ‘underestimated’.
She said: ‘Both the industry and the Government need to shoulder the responsibility for the chaos that we’ve seen.’
Ms Davies acknowledged that the sector has been ‘particularly affected’ by the coronavirus pandemic, but stressed that consumers have ‘lost money and suffered huge emotional stress’.
She went on: ‘Particularly appallingly, we’ve been hearing from lots of people who have just had very little information about actually what’s happening on the ground.
‘The airlines and the Government were encouraging people to travel again, and we think they’ve just underestimated the capacity issues, and the shortages both within the airlines and the airport services, including baggage handlers.’
Ms Davies accused airlines of selling tickets when ‘they don’t know for sure that those flights are actually going to be able to go’.
She told the committee that passengers ‘haven’t really been given proper information about their rights’, adding: ‘We feel that obviously there’s some really specific issues at the moment in this case, but this is just symptomatic of some of the issues that we’ve seen in the industry for a long time.
‘There’s just blatant flouting of consumer rights and a failure to put passenger interests first.’
She also told MPs: ‘Both the industry and the Government need to shoulder the responsibility for the chaos that we’ve seen.’
Meanwhile, for passengers, the chaos continued today. Passengers at Manchester Airport say they arrived three hours early for their flights, only to have to be pulled from the queues and fast-tracked through to the gate to avoid missing their flights.
Others say hundreds of passengers were being funnelled through just two security desks. Another passenger described the situation as a ‘fiasco’.
It comes after weeks of disruption at the airport, and others such as Birmingham and Bristol, and also on occasion Heathrow and Gatwick.
Passengers queue outside Terminal One at Manchester Airport earlier this month amid half-term travel chaos
Holidaymakers flying from Bristol Airport encountered lengthy queues before 4am on Monday despite arriving early
A shortage of airline and security staff combined with a sudden rush in demand for travel following the lifting of Covid restrictions has been blamed. It has also led to thousands of flights being cancelled in recent weeks.
Industry chiefs and Government bosses have been engaged in a bitter briefing war blaming each other for the problems.
Yesterday industry bodies cranked up the pressure on airlines and airports to deal with the continuing chaos, urging bosses to ensure the ‘unacceptable scenes’ at British airports do not drag on into summer.
The regulator, the Civil Aviation Authority (CAA), and the Department for Transport (DfT) urged carriers to ensure planned flights are ‘deliverable’.
The warning came as consumer group Which? said firms were ‘blatantly flouting’ passenger rights through practices such as taking bookings for flights which may not be able to run.
Tens of thousands of passengers have been affected by flight cancellations and long queues at airports in recent months, particularly during Easter and last month’s half-term school holiday.
On yet another day of chaos at Manchester Airport, which has been one of the worst hit sites, passengers today complained of long queues at security.
One passenger, taking to Twitter, wrote: ‘If you’re travelling from Manchester Airport then get to the airport at least three hours early.
‘We got here three hours early this morning and have had to be pulled out of the queue and fast-tracked as otherwise would have missed our flight’.
Another wrote: To say Manchester Airport T1 is a s*** show would be an understatement! 3.40am joined security queue only three rows deep, still not got through hour later. Only two security bays open. If joining queue now and have flight in next two hours good luck to you. ‘
Andrea McCarthy wrote: ‘Manchester airport this morning dreadful. 50 mins for bags to arrive from Atlanta flight. Now stuck at security for over an hour. Needs sorted.
She later added: ‘Update on Manchester airport fiasco. Security totally unhelpful and would not expedite us.’
However others appeared to avoid the chaos. One wrote: ‘Flew from Manchester Airport. Yes there were queues but they were well managed and there was no free-for-all.
‘Plane left on time and landed early. Thank you to the very helpful and patient and staff.’
Source by